Chapter 4 - THE FIRST LIE

On Monday morning, I discovered that my purple witch hat was missing.
I hadn't expected to get the costume back immediately.
But I thought Karen might at least return the accessories.
The hat had been something I loved.
I had spent an entire afternoon decorating it with silver stars and carefully shaping the crooked point.
It was the one part of the costume that made it feel completely mine.
I checked my bedroom closet.
Then the hallway.
Then the laundry room.
Nothing.
At breakfast, I asked Ava.
"Have you seen my hat?"
She looked up from her cereal.
"What hat?"
"My witch hat."
"Oh."
She continued eating.
"Mom put it in my room."
"Can I have it back?"
Ava shrugged.
"I don't know. Mom said I could keep the costume for now."
I looked at Karen.
"How long is now?"
Karen didn't look up from her phone.
"Until we figure something out."
"What does that mean?"
"It means stop asking questions."
Dad entered the kitchen carrying his briefcase.
"What's going on?"
Karen answered before I could.
"Lily is upset because Ava is using the costume."
"I'm asking for my hat," I said.
Dad placed his briefcase on the counter.
"Can we please have one peaceful morning?"
I looked at him.
I had stopped expecting him to take my side.
But some part of me still hoped he might notice how unfair this was.
He didn't.
At school, Chloe noticed my mood immediately.
"You look like you didn't sleep."
"I didn't."
"What's wrong?"
I told her about the missing hat.
She frowned.
"Why don't you just ask for the whole costume back?"
"I did."
"And?"
"They said no."
Chloe stared at me.
"That's ridiculous."
We were walking toward our lockers when Madison joined us.
"Hey, did you hear about the Halloween pictures?"
I looked at her.
"What pictures?"
Madison showed me her phone.
Someone had posted photographs from Saturday's party.
Ava appeared in several.
One of the pictures had been uploaded by a girl named Brooke.
The caption read:
Ava Mitchell absolutely won Halloween. Best costume in the whole school!
There were twenty-seven comments.
I scrolled.
One caught my attention.
Where did you get that dress? My daughter would love it.
Ava had replied:
My mom found it for me.
I handed the phone back.
Chloe looked furious.
"She really said that?"
I shrugged.
"Apparently."
Madison leaned closer.
"Wait. Didn't you buy that?"
I nodded.
"With your savings?"
"Yes."
Madison shook her head.
"That's so wrong."
For the first time, I felt relieved that someone else knew.
But the relief didn't last.
During lunch, my English teacher, Mrs. Whitaker, asked me to stay behind.
"Lily, can I speak with you?"
I waited until the other students left.
She smiled gently.
"I noticed you seemed distracted today."
"I'm okay."
She studied me.
"Are you sure?"
I nodded.
She opened a folder.
"Your writing assignment was excellent, by the way."
I looked up.
"Really?"
"Really. Especially the section about the difference between fairness and kindness."
I felt my cheeks warm.
"Thank you."
She closed the folder.
"Sometimes people confuse being kind with always giving in. Those aren't the same thing."
I stared at her.
She couldn't possibly know.
Could she?
She continued.
"Kindness should be a choice. Otherwise, it stops being kindness."
I swallowed.
"Can I ask you something?"
"Of course."
"If someone buys something with their own money, does someone else get to take it just because they're family?"
Mrs. Whitaker didn't answer immediately.
"No," she said finally. "Being family doesn't erase someone's right to their belongings."
I looked down.
"Even if the other person is upset?"
"Even then."
I nodded.
I didn't tell her what had happened.
But I wanted to.
I wanted to tell someone who wouldn't immediately explain why I was wrong.
When I returned home that afternoon, Karen was waiting in the kitchen.
She had a stack of papers beside her.
"Lily, we need to discuss something."
I put down my backpack.
"What?"
She pushed one of the papers toward me.
It was a printed screenshot from the family group chat.
My stomach tightened.
The message was from Karen.
Ava finally got to enjoy Halloween. Lily had a little trouble understanding that family means sharing, but we're working on it.
There were several responses.
One of Karen's friends had written:
Poor Ava. I'm glad you stepped in. Some children need to learn that the world doesn't revolve around them.
Another person had added:
You're doing a wonderful job blending the family.
I looked up.
"Why did you send this?"
Karen folded her arms.
"Because people deserve to know what happened."
"But you didn't tell them the truth."
Her expression hardened.
"Excuse me?"
"You told them I refused to share. You didn't tell them I bought the costume."
Karen took a slow breath.
"That's enough."
I pointed at the paper.
"They think you bought it for Ava."
"Nobody said that."
"She said it at school."
Karen looked toward the stairs.
Then back at me.
"You're making a mountain out of nothing."
I picked up my backpack.
As I turned to leave, Karen spoke again.
"And Lily?"
I stopped.
"Don't discuss family matters with your friends or teachers. We don't need people misunderstanding our situation."
I looked at her.
For the first time, I understood what she was really asking.
She didn't want me to stop arguing.
She wanted me to stop telling people what had happened.
I walked upstairs without answering.
Inside my room, I opened the blue notebook.
I wrote:
November 2 — Karen told people that I refused to share. She did not tell them I bought the costume myself.
Then I added:
She told me not to talk about it.
I stared at the words.
May you like
Something was happening.
And I was no longer certain it was only about a Halloween dress.