talehub

Chapter 3 - THE BROTHER WHO NEVER EXISTED

The first person to move was Daniel.

He rushed toward the wooden compartment beneath the altar and pulled at its edges.

"Father!"

Eleanor grabbed his wrist.

"Don't."

"Let go!"

"Listen to me."

"That's my father!"

"That man has spent twenty-three years teaching people how to disappear. Do you really think he would leave you an unlocked door?"

Daniel turned on her.

"Who is knocking?"

Eleanor looked toward the floor.

"Thomas."

Daniel laughed bitterly.

"Thomas is dead."

"Then why are you afraid?"

He went silent.

Behind them, the church organ suddenly produced a low, dissonant note.

The priest crossed himself.

"Someone should call the police."

Eleanor glanced at the locked entrance.

"They can't come in."

"Then unlock the doors!" a woman shouted.

Eleanor ignored her.

She walked to the center of the altar and removed a small silver pin from her wedding dress.

It was shaped like a key.

Daniel recognized it.

His father had owned an identical one.

"Where did you get that?"

"From the man who taught me what your father really was."

"Who?"

"Your father's brother."

Daniel shook his head.

"You expect me to believe a man who died twenty-three years ago is alive?"

"I expect you to believe the evidence."

She inserted the silver pin into a narrow opening beneath the altar.

A mechanism clicked.

The marble floor shifted slightly.

A rectangular panel opened.

Inside was a staircase.

Cold air rose from below.

The smell of dust, damp stone, and something metallic filled the church.

Daniel stared.

"There is a basement?"

"Not on the official building plans."

Eleanor descended three steps.

"Come with me."

Daniel didn't move.

"Why should I trust you?"

She looked back.

"Because eleven months ago, when the car exploded, you were the last person I called."

Daniel's face tightened.

He remembered.

Of course he remembered.

It had been 10:16 p.m.

He was reviewing evidence for a corruption trial when his phone rang.

Eleanor's name appeared on the screen.

He had answered.

"Hey, Eleanor. You still working?"

Her breathing was uneven.

"Daniel, I need you to listen."

He had smiled.

"What's wrong?"

"I found something in your father's files."

"What kind of something?"

"Something about the twins."

His smile disappeared.

"What twins?"

A crash.

Then a man's voice in the background.

Eleanor whispered:

"Don't trust—"

The call ended.

Twenty-three minutes later, a car exploded on Route 128.

The license plate belonged to Eleanor.

The dental records were inconclusive, but a ring recovered from the wreckage matched one she had worn for years.

The state declared her dead.

Daniel had attended the memorial.

He had stood beside her empty coffin.

And now she was standing in front of him.

Alive.

He looked at her.

"What did you find?"

Eleanor waited.

"Your father's original birth records."

Daniel's throat tightened.

"Show me."

She descended the stairs.

This time, he followed.

The underground passage was narrow and poorly lit.

Its walls were covered in old stonework.

At the bottom was a small chamber containing filing cabinets, shelves, and several electronic monitors.

A large metal door stood at the far end.

Daniel examined the room.

"This isn't part of the cathedral."

"No."

"How long has it been here?"

"Since 1999."

He turned.

"Who built it?"

"Your father."

Daniel approached the filing cabinets.

Hundreds of folders were arranged by year.

He saw names.

Federal judges.

Police officers.

Prosecutors.

Witnesses.

And then he saw his own.

DANIEL WHITMORE — 1984.

He pulled the folder out.

Inside was a birth certificate.

But the name at the top wasn't Daniel Whitmore.

It read:

DANIEL THOMAS MERCER.

Mother: Unknown.

Father: Thomas Whitmore.

Date of Birth: September 18, 1984.

Daniel stared at the document.

"That's impossible."

Eleanor stood behind him.

"Your father adopted you."

"No."

"He changed your name when you were six months old."

"No."

"He erased Thomas from the record."

Daniel slammed the folder onto the cabinet.

"My father raised me!"

"Yes."

"He loved me!"

Eleanor's expression softened.

"I know."

"Then why would he do this?"

"Because Thomas was the man he betrayed."

Daniel looked at the next document.

A photograph.

Two identical men stood outside a courthouse.

One wore a military uniform.

The other wore a dark suit.

Their faces were nearly indistinguishable.

Except for the scar on the left man's cheek.

The same scar from the photograph in the miniature coffin.

Daniel picked it up.

"Which one is my father?"

"The man without the scar."

"And the other?"

"Thomas."

He looked at the photograph again.

"Why does he look exactly like my father?"

Eleanor took a breath.

"Because they were identical twins."

Daniel's stomach tightened.

"You're saying Thomas was my biological father?"

"Yes."

"And Nathaniel was his brother?"

"Yes."

Daniel stepped backward.

His entire childhood began rearranging itself.

The man who had taught him to ride a bicycle.

The man who had sat beside his hospital bed.

The man who had attended his high school graduation.

The man who had helped him prepare for law school.

All of it had been real.

But the foundation beneath it had been built on a lie.

Daniel looked at Eleanor.

"Why?"

She opened another file.

Inside was a photograph of a young woman holding two babies.

One baby was wrapped in blue.

The other in white.

On the back, someone had written:

SEPTEMBER 18, 1984. THE LAST DAY OF THE MERCER FAMILY.

Daniel read the sentence twice.

"Who is she?"

Eleanor's voice became barely audible.

"Your mother."

He stared at the photograph.

"Is she alive?"

Eleanor didn't answer immediately.

Then she said:

"She was."

A silence settled between them.

Daniel's eyes filled.

"Was?"

Eleanor nodded.

"She died three days after your birth."

"How?"

"According to the official record, complications from childbirth."

"And according to the truth?"

Eleanor looked at the metal door.

"She was murdered."

A loud bang shook the chamber.

Daniel turned.

Something struck the other side of the metal door.

Once.

Twice.

Then a voice came through.

"Daniel?"

It sounded exactly like his father.

"Son, open the door."

Daniel approached.

Eleanor grabbed his shoulder.

"Don't."

The voice spoke again.

"Daniel, please."

His eyes filled.

"Father?"

The voice lowered.

"Your brother is waiting."

Then a second voice came from the other side.

A man's voice.

Older.

Rougher.

"Hello, little brother."

May you like

Daniel stopped breathing.

Because the second voice sounded exactly like his own.

Related Stories

Other posts