talehub

Chapter 9 - THE GRANDMOTHER'S DARKEST SECRET

Margaret Vale had never been afraid of a gun.

She had watched men die over less than three pounds. She had balanced the accounts of murderers, bribed policemen, negotiated with politicians, and survived three attempts on her life.

But when Lily placed the photograph on the desk, Margaret looked like a woman who had finally reached the end of a very long road.

Arthur stood motionless.

His brother Edward was beside him. His father, William, remained near the library entrance, surrounded by men carrying weapons.

Nobody spoke.

Arthur picked up the photograph.

It showed Elizabeth Carter standing beside Margaret outside a railway station. Elizabeth looked younger than he remembered, perhaps twenty-three. Her hair was tied beneath a dark scarf, and one hand rested protectively over her stomach.

Margaret was smiling.

On the back, Elizabeth had written:

If Margaret ever tells you the truth, remember that she was the one who gave the order.

Arthur read the sentence again.

Then he looked at the old woman.

"Did you order Elizabeth's death?"

Margaret's lips trembled.

"Yes."

Arthur raised his revolver.

The men around the room immediately shifted.

Edward reached for his brother's arm.

"Arthur, wait."

"Get away from me."

"Listen to her."

"She ordered my daughter's mother murdered!"

Margaret closed her eyes.

"I did."

Arthur's finger tightened around the trigger.

"Why?"

The old woman opened her eyes.

"Because Elizabeth asked me to."

The answer was so unexpected that Arthur momentarily forgot to breathe.

"What?"

Margaret walked toward the desk.

"Your father had discovered that Elizabeth was carrying your child. He intended to take the baby and use her as leverage over both you and Edward. He had already arranged for Thomas Carter to disappear."

Arthur shook his head.

"That doesn't explain the photograph."

"No. But it explains why Elizabeth came to me."

Margaret removed a small envelope from her dress.

It was yellowed with age.

Inside was a handwritten letter.

Arthur recognized Elizabeth's handwriting immediately.

Margaret,

If you are reading this, the arrangements have failed.

I cannot stay in Birmingham. William has discovered Lily's existence, and Thomas believes he has only a few days before they find him.

I need you to make everyone believe that I am dead.

I know what I am asking. I know you will hate me for it.

But if Arthur believes I am alive, he will search for me. If William discovers that I am alive, he will use me to control Arthur.

I would rather have my daughter grow up without a father than watch her become another prisoner of the Blackwood name.

Please protect her.

Elizabeth.

Arthur lowered the letter.

"She wasn't murdered?"

Margaret shook her head.

"Not by me."

"Then why did you tell me she was dead?"

"Because I had to make the story convincing. Elizabeth disappeared during the factory fire. Thomas escaped with Lily. I arranged the false identification, the empty coffin, and the death certificates."

Arthur stared at her.

"You let me bury an empty coffin."

"I let you grieve a woman who was alive."

"Do you understand what you did to me?"

Margaret's expression broke.

"Every day."

Arthur turned away.

For eight years, he had visited Elizabeth's grave on the anniversary of her death. He had left flowers, whiskey, and sometimes letters he never intended anyone to read.

He had spoken to a stone.

He had apologized to an empty coffin.

And all that time, the woman responsible had been sitting somewhere in Birmingham, watching his life unfold.

"Where is Elizabeth?" he demanded.

Margaret looked at Lily.

The little girl lowered her eyes.

Arthur noticed immediately.

"Where is she?"

Edward answered.

"Arthur, Elizabeth died in 1922."

The room became silent again.

Arthur slowly turned toward him.

"How?"

"She was found in a boardinghouse outside Manchester. She had been living under another name. She became ill after years of moving between safe houses."

Arthur swallowed.

"Did she suffer?"

Edward didn't answer immediately.

That was enough.

Arthur closed his eyes.

"Did she ask about me?"

"Every time I saw her."

"Did she hate me?"

Edward shook his head.

"No. She was afraid of what you had become, but she never stopped loving you."

Arthur looked toward Lily.

"Does she know I wanted her back?"

Lily nodded.

"She knew."

Arthur knelt before his daughter.

"Did your mother ever tell you about me?"

"Yes."

"What did she say?"

Lily thought for a moment.

"She said you used to whistle when you were nervous. She said you hated boiled carrots. She said you once stole a policeman's hat because you thought it looked better than yours."

Arthur almost smiled.

"She remembered that?"

"She remembered everything."

Lily reached into her coat and removed a folded piece of fabric.

It was a small blue ribbon.

"My mother gave me this before she died. She said it belonged to you."

Arthur took it.

His name was embroidered in tiny white letters.

A.

BLACKWOOD.

He pressed the ribbon against his palm.

Then Lily said something that made his heart stop.

"She also said that if you ever found me, I should ask you why you didn't come looking sooner."

Arthur looked at her.

"I did look."

"Not hard enough."

He had no answer.

Margaret turned toward Edward.

"There's another problem."

Edward's expression hardened.

"William?"

"No."

She looked at Lily.

"The man who gave the final order against Elizabeth is still alive."

Arthur stood.

"Who?"

Margaret hesitated.

Then she pointed toward the old grandfather clock.

"Your mother."

Arthur frowned.

"My mother died in 1915."

Margaret shook her head.

May you like

"Your mother never died, Arthur."

And somewhere upstairs, a telephone began ringing.

Related Stories

Other posts