talehub

Chapter 5 - THE BOY WHO WORE THE WRONG NAME

The next morning, Vincent visited St. Bartholomew's Cemetery.

He brought Daniel, Eleanor, Rosie, and six armed men.

The cemetery stood on the outskirts of Birmingham, surrounded by iron fencing and dead trees.

Mist hung over the graves.

Rosie walked beside her father, holding his hand.

"Is this where you were buried?" she asked Daniel.

"According to the records."

"Did you see your grave?"

"No."

"Then how do you know?"

Daniel looked at her.

"Because somebody sent me a photograph."

Rosie considered this.

"Adults believe strange things."

Daniel smiled.

"You're not wrong."

They reached section seventeen.

A row of neglected graves stood beneath an enormous oak tree.

Vincent examined the inscriptions.

Most belonged to men who had died between 1917 and 1919.

At the end of the row stood a small headstone.

It carried Daniel Carter's name.

Vincent approached it.

The inscription read:

Daniel Carter. Beloved friend. 1891–1918.

He knelt.

The earth beneath the stone looked unusually fresh.

"Dig."

Two men began removing the soil.

After several minutes, their shovels struck wood.

They uncovered a narrow coffin.

Vincent ordered everyone back.

He opened it himself.

Inside lay a skeleton wearing Daniel's old coat.

A brass identification tag rested against its chest.

But the body was too small.

Vincent stared.

"This isn't Daniel."

Daniel examined the remains.

"No."

Rosie leaned forward.

"Who's inside?"

Nobody answered.

Daniel carefully lifted the brass tag.

The name had been scratched away.

Beneath it were two letters.

J.C.

Eleanor began trembling.

Vincent noticed.

"What?"

She looked at the coffin.

"Jonathan."

Daniel turned toward her.

"You recognize the name?"

Eleanor nodded.

"Jonathan Carter."

Vincent looked between them.

"Who was he?"

Daniel closed his eyes.

"My younger brother."

Vincent stepped backward.

Daniel had never mentioned having a brother.

"Why was he buried under your name?"

"Because Arthur needed somebody to die in my place."

Daniel stared at the small skeleton.

"Jonathan was seventeen."

Rosie looked up.

"Was he your brother?"

"Yes."

"Did he know you were alive?"

Daniel shook his head.

"He believed he was helping me escape."

Vincent's jaw tightened.

"Arthur killed him?"

Daniel nodded.

"He dressed Jonathan in my clothes and arranged the execution."

"Then the body I watched?"

"Was Jonathan."

Vincent looked toward the headstone.

For ten years, he had believed he ordered his friend killed.

Instead, he had witnessed the murder of an innocent seventeen-year-old boy.

A terrible silence settled over the cemetery.

Then Rosie noticed something.

"Papa."

Daniel looked at her.

"There's writing."

She pointed beneath the coffin.

A metal box had been hidden in the earth.

Vincent opened it.

Inside were several documents, a photograph, and a small silver bracelet.

The photograph showed three children.

Two boys and a baby girl.

The older boys stood beside a woman.

Vincent recognized the woman as Eleanor.

The taller boy was Daniel.

The younger one was Jonathan.

The baby girl was wrapped in a white blanket.

On the back, someone had written:

The three children of the Blackwood inheritance.

Vincent frowned.

"What inheritance?"

Eleanor examined the picture.

"I've never seen this."

Daniel looked at the baby.

His expression changed.

"That can't be right."

"Why?" Vincent asked.

"Because that baby was supposed to be dead."

Rosie looked at the picture.

"Who is she?"

Daniel swallowed.

"Her name was Grace."

"Where is she now?"

Nobody answered.

A distant whistle interrupted them.

One of Vincent's guards ran toward the group.

"Boss! There's a boy at the cemetery gate."

Vincent turned.

"How old?"

"About ten."

"What's he doing?"

The guard hesitated.

"He says he's waiting for his father."

Vincent looked toward Daniel.

Daniel's face had become completely pale.

"What's his name?" he asked.

The guard answered.

"Jonathan."

Daniel walked toward the gate.

A thin boy stood beneath the iron archway.

He wore a brown coat and a flat cap.

His face was dirty, and his right cheek carried a fresh bruise.

But his eyes were familiar.

Daniel stopped several feet away.

"Who are you?"

The boy looked at him.

"You're supposed to know."

Daniel took another step.

"Your name?"

"Jonathan Carter."

Vincent raised his weapon slightly.

"That's impossible."

The boy looked past him.

Then his eyes settled on Rosie.

"Hello, sister."

Rosie froze.

And Daniel realized that the coffin in the cemetery had not contained his brother's body.

May you like

It had contained the body of someone else.

Someone whose identity had been deliberately erased.

Related Stories

Other posts