talehub

Chapter 2 - The Doctor Who Knew Too Much

Dr. Everett Hale was waiting in the blue sitting room when Santiago came downstairs.

He looked exactly as Santiago remembered him: silver hair, expensive glasses, a navy suit that appeared immune to wrinkles, and an expression of professional concern that had comforted the Moretti family through some of its darkest years.

He stood when Santiago entered.

"Santiago. I'm sorry to arrive without an appointment."

"You've never needed one."

Hale smiled faintly.

"How is Sophia?"

"Why don't you tell me?"

The doctor paused.

Only for a moment, but Santiago noticed.

"I beg your pardon?"

"You've treated my sister for seven years. You know her medical history better than anyone. Tell me how she is."

Hale removed his glasses.

"She has good days and bad days."

"That's not an answer."

"It's the truth. Sophia's neurological condition is complex. Progress isn't always linear."

"Has she ever been able to communicate more effectively than she does now?"

Hale's expression grew cautious.

"Define effectively."

"She laughs. She understands conversations. She can communicate through gestures. Apparently, she can tell someone that she hates the color of her bedsheets and that her brother is an idiot."

Hale's eyebrows rose.

"She's said that?"

Santiago watched him carefully.

"Would it surprise you if she had?"

"No. Not at all. I have always maintained that Sophia possesses more comprehension than she can express verbally."

"Have you?"

"Of course."

"Then why have you spent seven years telling me not to expect meaningful communication?"

Hale placed his glasses on the table.

"Because there is a difference between comprehension and reliable communication. Sophia has experienced significant trauma. Pushing her beyond her limits can cause distress."

"Ruby Brennan didn't seem worried about distress."

The doctor's expression changed.

There it was again.

A brief, unmistakable flicker.

Recognition.

"You know Ruby Brennan?" Santiago asked.

Hale recovered quickly.

"I know of her."

"From where?"

"Her employment at St. Catherine's. She was involved in a difficult case."

"My understanding is that the case involved her brother."

"That was part of it."

"What was the other part?"

Hale took a slow breath.

"Ruby was emotionally involved in her brother's treatment. Understandably, she found it difficult to maintain professional boundaries."

"Did she harm him?"

"No."

The answer came too quickly.

Santiago leaned forward.

"Did she?"

Hale held his gaze.

"No. Not deliberately."

The distinction landed between them like a stone.

"You're choosing your words carefully, Doctor."

"I am choosing them accurately."

"Then be accurate about this. What happened to Sophia on October fourteenth, seven years ago?"

Hale's face went still.

"Why are you asking about that date?"

"Because my sister remembers it."

"Memory can be complicated in patients with trauma."

"That's not what I asked."

The doctor stood and moved toward the window.

"October fourteenth was a significant day in Sophia's treatment history. We attempted an alternative communication protocol."

"What kind?"

"A structured sensory intervention."

"What did it involve?"

"Nothing unusual. A controlled environment, limited stimulation, and a sequence of guided responses."

"Did she speak?"

"No."

"Did she stop speaking that day?"

Hale turned.

"She had been withdrawing for some time."

"Was there an incident?"

The doctor hesitated.

"She became distressed."

"How?"

"She experienced a severe panic response. Her heart rate increased. She struggled to regulate her breathing. We discontinued the session."

"Who was present?"

"Me. A nurse. Your father."

Santiago's hands went still on the arms of his chair.

"My father?"

"Yes."

"My father was present during Sophia's treatment?"

"He wanted to observe the session."

"Why didn't anyone tell me?"

"You were away."

"Where?"

Hale's lips tightened.

"At a business meeting, I believe."

Santiago had been twenty-four at the time. Their father had begun introducing him to the family businesses, sending him to meetings and negotiations that lasted days.

He remembered that autumn as a blur of long drives, sleepless nights, and the growing tension between his father and his uncle, Vittorio.

He did not remember Sophia receiving a special treatment session.

"Was my mother there?"

"No."

"Did my father tell me about it?"

"I assumed he did."

"You assumed."

Hale sighed.

"Santiago, I understand your frustration, but this is not productive. Sophia has spent years receiving care from qualified professionals. She has never been neglected."

"She told me someone visited her three years ago."

The doctor became motionless.

"Who?"

"That's what I'm asking you."

"I don't recall anyone unusual."

"Ruby Brennan?"

"No."

The denial was immediate.

Santiago rose.

"You're lying."

Hale's face hardened.

"I beg your pardon?"

"I've spent my life around men who lie for money, for power, for survival. I know what it looks like when someone answers a question before considering the consequences."

"You're making an accusation based on a few gestures from a severely traumatized young woman."

"She's nineteen."

"That doesn't change her condition."

"Neither does your degree change the fact that she's a person."

Hale's expression shifted.

For a moment, the professional mask slipped, revealing irritation beneath it.

"I have dedicated seven years to helping your sister."

"And I've paid you enough money to buy a small hospital."

"That money has never influenced my treatment decisions."

"Then you won't mind if I obtain every record connected to her care."

Hale stared at him.

"Those records are confidential."

"She's my sister."

"Confidentiality still applies."

"Then ask her permission."

The doctor said nothing.

Santiago stepped toward the door.

"Until I understand what happened on October fourteenth, I don't want you treating Sophia."

"That would be a mistake."

"Perhaps."

"She needs consistency."

"Then you should have given it to her."

Hale collected his briefcase.

At the doorway, he stopped.

"One final piece of advice, Santiago. Be careful about bringing strangers into a vulnerable patient's life. People sometimes mistake emotional attachment for therapeutic skill."

Santiago looked at him.

"Are you talking about Ruby?"

"I'm talking about anyone who encourages Sophia to believe that her condition is someone else's fault."

"Did someone tell her it was her fault?"

Hale's mouth closed.

The silence lasted one second too long.

Then he walked out.

Santiago watched him leave through the front entrance.

He waited until the car had disappeared before calling Tomas.

"Find out everything you can about October fourteenth, seven years ago."

"Anything specific?"

"Hospital records. Appointment schedules. Names of the staff who were present. I want to know where my father was, what he was doing, and why I never heard about that session."

"I'll start now."

"And Tomas?"

"Yes?"

"Find Ruby."

"We're still looking."

"Then look harder."

After ending the call, Santiago returned upstairs.

Sophia was sitting in the same position, staring at the paper on which she had written the date.

He sat beside her.

"Dr. Hale says he doesn't remember anyone unusual visiting you three years ago."

Sophia's expression turned bitter.

She wrote:

He remembers everything.

"Why did he lie?"

She shook her head.

Then she wrote:

He thinks I can't prove it.

Santiago felt a cold pressure settle behind his ribs.

"What happened three years ago?"

Sophia stared at the page.

Her pencil moved slowly.

Someone came to help me.

"Who?"

Ruby.

Santiago exhaled.

"Ruby came here three years ago?"

Sophia nodded.

"Before she worked for us?"

Another nod.

"How did she know you?"

Sophia turned the page and wrote:

Daniel.

Santiago remembered the file.

Ruby's younger brother.

The boy who had died at St. Catherine's.

"Daniel knew you?"

Sophia nodded again.

Then she wrote a sentence that changed the shape of the mystery.

Daniel was my friend before he died.

Santiago stared at her.

"How?"

Sophia's fingers trembled.

She drew a small box.

Inside it, she wrote:

He helped me talk.

The room fell silent.

Santiago looked at his sister, then at the words.

For seven years, he had believed that Sophia's silence was the tragic consequence of losing their parents.

But she was telling him something else.

Daniel Brennan had helped her communicate.

And Ruby Brennan had come to the Moretti mansion three years ago, carrying a connection to a boy who had died under suspicious circumstances.

"Why didn't you tell me?"

Sophia looked at him.

Her eyes filled with tears.

She wrote:

I tried.

Santiago's throat tightened.

"When?"

She pointed toward the hallway.

Then toward the floor beneath them.

Then she made a gesture that he had seen her use when she was frightened.

The gesture for door.

Santiago understood.

He had heard her outside his study. He had seen her standing at the end of corridors, waiting for him to finish a call. He had noticed her watching him during family dinners.

He had always interpreted those moments as confusion or anxiety.

He had never asked what she was trying to say.

He lowered his head.

"I'm sorry."

Sophia did not reach for him.

She did not smile.

She simply turned the page.

Find Ruby.

Santiago nodded.

"I will."

Then she wrote something else.

May you like

Something that made him stop breathing for a moment.

Before Uncle Vittorio finds her.

Related Stories

Other posts