talehub

Chapter 4 - The Family Story

Ryan Hayes was waiting outside Elise's room when Nia returned from the consultation area.

He stood beside a vending machine, wearing the same navy sweater he'd apparently worn the previous evening. His hair was disheveled, and a day's worth of stubble darkened his jaw.

When he saw her, relief crossed his face.

Then he noticed her expression.

"How is she?"

"Sleeping."

"Can I see her?"

"She's your daughter. The nurse will tell you when it's appropriate."

He flinched at the distance in her voice.

"Nia, please."

She stopped a few feet away.

"Why did you wait twenty minutes before taking her to the hospital?"

"I told you. I was trying to understand what happened."

"You found your daughter injured, and your first instinct was to investigate?"

"I panicked."

"Then say that."

Ryan looked away.

"I panicked."

For the first time, his answer sounded honest.

Nia studied him.

She remembered this man as he had been years earlier, before the arguments became a daily ritual. Ryan had once held Elise against his chest and whispered promises to her while she slept. He had painted the nursery himself, making a mess of the walls and laughing when Nia teased him about the uneven corners.

He wasn't a stranger.

That made his failures harder to accept.

"Tell me what happened," she said.

Ryan rubbed both hands over his face.

"I got home around eight. Elise was supposed to be at Tessa's for dinner. Morgan had picked her up from school because I was working late."

"Why were they both there?"

"Tessa said she wanted to spend time with Elise."

"And you agreed?"

"Yes."

"Did you know they planned to make her record a video?"

"No."

"Did you know they were angry with her?"

"I knew Tessa had been upset about something. I didn't know it was this."

Nia waited.

Ryan took a breath.

"When I got home, Elise was in the guest room. She was curled up on the bed, crying. Tessa told me she'd fallen in the garage."

"Where was Morgan?"

"Downstairs."

"And Elise?"

"She wouldn't look at me."

"What did you do?"

"I asked what happened. She said she wanted you."

Nia felt her jaw tighten.

"What did you do then?"

"I told her I would call you after we got her checked out."

"Why didn't you call an ambulance immediately?"

"I thought she might have a broken arm. Tessa said she had slipped."

"Did you see the injuries?"

"Some of them."

"Then how could you believe it was a simple fall?"

Ryan stared at the floor.

"I didn't. Not really."

The admission hung between them.

Nia's voice became quieter.

"Did you know your sisters had hurt her?"

"No."

"Did you suspect?"

He looked up.

"I suspected something was wrong."

"That's not the same as saying no."

"I didn't know what to do."

"You were her father."

The words struck him harder than shouting would have.

Ryan swallowed.

"I know."

"No, Ryan. I don't think you do. You keep talking about what you didn't know, what you couldn't understand, what you were afraid of. Elise was lying in a room with broken bones, and she needed you to protect her. What did you do?"

He had no answer.

Nia stepped back.

"I can't have this conversation here."

"Please don't shut me out."

"I'm not shutting you out. I'm asking you to be honest."

"I am being honest."

"Then tell the police everything. Tell them what Tessa said the night before. Tell them about the video. Tell them why you were so afraid to challenge your sisters."

Ryan's face drained of color.

"How do you know about the night before?"

"You told me on the phone."

He shook his head.

"I shouldn't have said anything."

Nia stared at him.

"Why?"

Ryan glanced down the corridor.

For a moment, she thought he might answer.

Instead, he whispered, "You don't understand what they're capable of."

Nia felt a cold line of anger move through her.

"I understand exactly what they're capable of. I've seen the result."

"That's not what I meant."

"Then explain."

He opened his mouth, but a nurse appeared at the end of the corridor and called his name.

"Mr. Hayes? Detective Ortiz would like to speak with you."

Ryan looked at Nia.

"Can we talk later?"

"That depends on what you tell the detective."

He followed the nurse away.

Nia stood alone beside the vending machine.

She had spent years believing Ryan's greatest weakness was his need to please everyone. He hated conflict. He wanted every disagreement resolved without anyone being angry with him.

But there was something more troubling beneath that weakness.

Fear.

Not ordinary fear of embarrassment or family arguments.

The kind of fear that made a grown man hesitate to challenge his own sisters even when his daughter was bleeding.

Nia returned to Elise's room.

Her daughter was awake and watching the door.

"Did Dad come?" Elise asked.

"Yes."

"Is he mad at me?"

"No, sweetheart."

Elise looked uncertain.

"He's not mad?"

"No."

"Because Aunt Morgan said he'd be disappointed."

Nia sat beside her.

"Elise, grown-ups sometimes say things to make children feel responsible for decisions that aren't theirs. You are not responsible for your father's feelings. You are not responsible for your aunts' behavior. You are not responsible for what happened."

Elise picked at the edge of her blanket.

"They said everybody knows you left us."

Nia took a slow breath.

"Who told you that?"

"Grandma. Aunt Tessa. Aunt Morgan."

Nia's heart sank.

"Grandma told you that?"

Elise nodded.

"She said you chose the Army because you didn't want to be a real mom."

Nia stared at her daughter's small face.

Her former mother-in-law, Margaret Hayes, had always been more subtle than her daughters. She had never shouted at Nia or openly insulted her. Instead, she used a quiet voice and disappointed expressions to make cruel statements sound like reasonable observations.

Nia remembered the last time Margaret had visited her house.

She had stood in the kitchen, watching Elise play with blocks on the floor, and remarked that children needed their mothers more than they needed the country.

Nia had answered that children needed parents who taught them honesty, responsibility, and courage.

Margaret had smiled.

"Those are lovely ideals, Nia. But ideals don't tuck a child into bed."

At the time, Nia had let the remark pass.

She regretted that now.

"Did Grandma know about the video?" Nia asked.

Elise hesitated.

"She told them they had to fix the story."

"What story?"

"The one about you."

Nia felt a chill.

"Did she say anything else?"

Elise closed her eyes.

"She said people were asking questions. She said the family couldn't look bad."

Nia leaned back.

This was no longer simply a matter of two aunts losing their tempers.

If Elise's account was accurate, Margaret had been involved in discussions about the video. That didn't prove she had participated in the assault, but it raised questions about what she knew before and afterward.

"Did Grandma see you get hurt?"

Elise's eyes opened.

"She was there before."

"Before what?"

"Before Aunt Morgan took me upstairs."

Nia kept her voice gentle.

"Did Grandma stay?"

"I don't know."

"That's okay."

Elise looked at the doorway.

"Mom, are they going to take me away?"

"No."

"What if Dad says I have to go back?"

"No one is going to make you go somewhere you don't feel safe without the proper people looking into it."

Elise nodded, but her fingers tightened around the blanket.

Nia reached for her hand.

"Do you remember what I told you when you were little and you were afraid of the dark?"

"That shadows aren't monsters."

"That's right."

Elise looked at her.

"But what if they are?"

Nia had no easy answer.

She brushed her daughter's hair back.

"Then we turn on the light."

Elise stared at her for a long moment.

Then she whispered, "I think Grandma knows where my tablet is."

Nia's hand stopped.

"Why do you think that?"

"Because she told Aunt Tessa not to worry about it."

Nia leaned closer.

"When did she say that?"

"Before I went upstairs."

"What did Aunt Tessa say?"

"She said the video wasn't on the tablet. She said they needed the real one."

Nia felt her pulse quicken.

The real one.

The recording Elise had made.

"Did Grandma know you had recorded them?"

Elise shook her head.

"I don't think so."

"Then why did she say that?"

"I don't know."

Nia let the question rest.

Her daughter was tired. The pain medication was making her drowsy, and she needed rest more than she needed another interrogation.

Nia kissed her forehead.

"That's enough for now. You don't have to remember everything today."

Elise's eyelids drooped.

"Will you be here when I wake up?"

"Yes."

"Promise?"

"I promise."

Nia waited until her daughter fell asleep.

Then she stepped into the corridor and called Detective Ortiz.

"I need to tell you something Elise said."

The detective listened as Nia explained the reference to Margaret, the discussion about fixing the family story, and the missing tablet.

"Did Elise say Margaret was present during the assault?" Ortiz asked.

"No. She said Margaret was there before she went upstairs. I don't know what happened after that."

"That's an important distinction. We'll document it accurately."

"What about the tablet?"

"We've asked Ryan to provide the devices he knows belong to Elise. So far, he hasn't produced the tablet."

"Has he explained why?"

"He says he hasn't found it."

Nia looked toward the hospital room.

"Then someone needs to look for it."

"We have officers at the residence."

"Can they search the garage?"

"They're documenting the scene and pursuing the appropriate authorization. I can't promise what they'll find."

Nia understood the caution.

But she also understood what happened when people were given time to clean up after themselves.

"Detective, I heard a man on the recording asking about a second copy."

Ortiz paused.

"Yes. I've noted that."

"Do you have any idea who he is?"

"Not yet."

"Could he be connected to the family?"

"Possibly. But we're not going to guess."

Nia ended the call and leaned against the wall.

She needed to remain patient.

The evidence would determine what happened, not her anger.

But patience had never felt so much like standing still while a storm gathered.

An hour later, Ryan returned.

He looked worse than before.

"The police asked me about the video," he said.

"What did you tell them?"

"Everything I know."

"Everything?"

He met her eyes.

"Yes."

Nia searched his face.

"And what did they say?"

"They want to speak to Tessa and Morgan again. They're also trying to locate Elise's tablet."

"Did you tell them about your mother?"

Ryan looked startled.

"How do you know about Mom?"

"Elise said she was there before the assault."

His face changed.

"She was there for dinner."

"Did you know they planned to make the video?"

"No."

"Did you know your mother was involved in that discussion?"

Ryan hesitated.

Nia felt the old, familiar anger rise.

"Ryan."

"I knew she wanted you to look bad."

"That's not what I asked."

He lowered his voice.

"Mom thought the video might help with the custody situation."

Nia stared at him.

"What custody situation?"

"The divorce agreement is being reviewed."

"By whom?"

"Mom's attorney."

Nia's stomach tightened.

"Why?"

Ryan looked toward the elevator.

"Because they think you might be reassigned. They think you'll be gone again for a long time."

"And they thought an eight-year-old girl should be forced to say her mother abandoned her?"

He closed his eyes.

"I didn't agree with that."

"But you knew they were trying to build a case against me."

"I knew they were talking about it."

"And you did nothing."

Ryan didn't answer.

Nia turned away.

For years, she had believed that the worst thing Ryan could do was fail to defend her when his family attacked her character.

Now she understood the greater danger.

He had allowed their version of the truth to become more important than his daughter's safety.

"Go home, Ryan."

He looked at her.

"What?"

"Go home. Speak to the police. Find out whether your daughter needs anything. But don't stand here asking me to comfort you because you're ashamed."

"Nia—"

"Not now."

He stood motionless.

Then he walked away.

Nia returned to Elise's bedside and sat down.

The family story had been carefully constructed over years. It portrayed Nia as the absent mother, Ryan as the exhausted parent left behind, and the Hayes women as generous relatives who filled the gaps.

But stories depended on what people left out.

They had left out the phone calls Nia made after long shifts.

The money she sent for Elise's school activities.

The drawings she kept beside her bed overseas.

The way she had asked Ryan to establish boundaries.

The way he had agreed, then allowed his family to ignore them.

And now they had left out the truth about what happened to Elise.

Nia looked at the hospital monitor.

The machine recorded every breath her daughter took.

Unlike the Hayes family, it didn't care how the story sounded.

May you like

It simply recorded what happened.

And somewhere in that house, a missing tablet might hold the same kind of truth.

Related Stories

Other posts