talehub

Chapter 1 - The Sister Who Stopped Calling

The first sign that something was wrong was not the wedding invitation Kayla declined.

It was the way my fiancé looked at my phone when her name appeared on the screen.

I noticed it on a Tuesday evening in April, three months before my wedding, while Tyler and I sat at our kitchen island eating takeout from the Italian restaurant down the street. Rain tapped against the windows of our apartment in Boston, and a half-finished wedding seating chart lay between us.

My phone vibrated.

KAYLA: Sorry. Can't make it Saturday.

That was all.

No explanation. No heart emoji. No promise to make it up to me.

I stared at the message, trying to decide whether to feel hurt or worried.

Tyler glanced at the screen.

Then he stopped chewing.

It was such a small thing that I might have missed it if I hadn't spent the last two years learning his expressions. Tyler had a way of revealing his emotions through the smallest betrayals of his face. A tightened jaw. A momentary narrowing of his eyes. The faintest pause before he answered a question.

"What is it?" I asked.

He swallowed. "What?"

"You looked like you saw a ghost."

He smiled, but it arrived a second too late.

"Long day at work."

I turned my phone facedown.

"Kayla canceled again."

"Maybe she's busy."

"She's been busy for three months."

He reached across the island and covered my hand with his. His fingers were warm, his wedding band absent because we hadn't married yet, and his thumb moved over my knuckles in the slow, reassuring rhythm I had come to associate with him.

"Rachel, sweetheart, not everyone gets excited about weddings the way you do."

I pulled my hand away.

"She's my sister."

"I know."

"She was the first person I called when you proposed. She cried harder than I did."

Tyler's expression softened.

"Maybe something's going on with her."

"That's what Mom keeps saying. But nobody will tell me what."

He looked toward the window.

For one strange second, I had the impression that he wanted to tell me something.

Then he picked up his fork.

"Give her time."

I wanted to believe him. I wanted to believe that the woman who had once promised to stand beside me through every important moment of my life was merely having a difficult season.

Instead, I kept thinking about the last time I had seen her.

It had been three weeks earlier, outside her apartment in Cambridge. I'd driven there after she ignored six calls and a dozen messages. I carried a bag of her favorite pastries from the bakery we used to visit as children, the one with the cinnamon rolls so enormous we could barely finish them.

I knocked.

"Kayla? It's me."

Nothing.

I knocked again.

"Come on, K. I'm not leaving until you talk to me."

I heard movement inside.

A floorboard creaked. Something brushed against the door.

Then her voice came through the wood.

"Go home, Rachel."

I froze.

"What's wrong?"

"Nothing."

"Then open the door."

"I can't."

The words had sounded so frightened that I immediately pressed my palm against the door.

"Can't, or won't?"

Silence.

Then, so quietly I almost didn't hear it, she said, "Please don't marry him."

I remember the sudden chill that traveled through me.

"What?"

A long pause followed.

"Kayla, what did you say?"

"I said I'm sick of talking about the wedding."

The change in her voice was immediate and unnatural, as though someone had flipped a switch.

"Go home."

I stood in that hallway for nearly ten minutes, holding the bag of pastries until the paper grew damp beneath my fingers.

When I finally walked away, I heard the deadbolt slide into place.

Now, sitting across from Tyler, I remembered those words.

Please don't marry him.

"Do you think I should go over there again?" I asked.

Tyler set down his fork.

"No."

His answer came too quickly.

I looked at him.

"Why not?"

"Because she's made it clear she doesn't want to talk."

"She's my sister."

"And you're about to get married. You have enough to worry about without chasing someone who refuses to answer the door."

Something in his tone bothered me. It wasn't impatience with Kayla. It sounded almost like fear.

I studied him.

"Have you talked to her?"

Tyler went still.

"What?"

"Have you talked to Kayla recently?"

"No."

He answered without hesitation, which should have reassured me.

Instead, I noticed that his left hand had curled into a fist beneath the counter.

I knew that gesture.

Tyler made it when he was trying very hard not to show anger.

I had seen him do it during a difficult business negotiation, once when a driver nearly hit us at a crosswalk, and again when his father called him an ungrateful disappointment over Thanksgiving dinner.

"Rachel," he said gently, "why would you ask me that?"

"I don't know."

It was the truth.

I didn't know why I had asked.

I only knew that, for the first time since Tyler had proposed beneath the lights of Boston Public Garden, I felt as though I were standing outside a locked door, listening to the people I loved whispering on the other side.

And I was beginning to suspect that the secret behind it had something to do with me.

I grew up believing that sisters were supposed to be permanent.

Our mother, Diane, had raised Kayla and me in a white clapboard house outside Worcester, Massachusetts. The house had peeling paint on the porch, a maple tree in the backyard, and a kitchen where our mother baked blueberry muffins every Sunday morning.

Our father, Michael Bennett, had died when I was seventeen and Kayla was thirteen.

A heart attack, the doctors said.

Sudden. Unavoidable. A terrible tragedy.

He had been a quiet man who repaired old radios in the basement and kept a jar of peppermint candies beside his favorite armchair. When he came home from work, Kayla would run to him and demand to be lifted into his arms, even when she was too old for it.

I was the practical sister. The responsible one.

I remembered school deadlines, paid bills when Mom forgot, and made sure Kayla never missed a doctor's appointment. When Dad died, I became even more responsible, because somebody had to.

Kayla became the bright one.

She could make our mother laugh on the worst days. She could walk into a room full of strangers and leave with five new friends. She had our father's crooked smile and a habit of singing under her breath when she was nervous.

We shared a bedroom until I left for college.

We fought over clothes, borrowed each other's makeup, and whispered beneath the blankets long after Mom told us to turn out the lights. When I had my first serious boyfriend, Kayla interrogated him over dinner as if she were a detective investigating a murder.

When she got her first job, I helped her write her résumé.

When I got promoted at work, she showed up at my apartment with cupcakes and cheap champagne.

When Tyler proposed, she screamed so loudly over the phone that I had to hold it away from my ear.

"Oh my God! Rachel! Oh my God!"

I laughed through tears.

"You haven't even seen the ring."

"I don't need to see the ring! You're getting married!"

She demanded every detail. The restaurant. The music. What Tyler had said. Whether I had cried. Whether he had cried.

Then she went quiet.

"You're going to be happy, right?"

I remember leaning against my kitchen counter, smiling at the ring on my finger.

"Yes, K. I really think I am."

"Good."

Her voice had softened.

"Because you deserve that."

For the next several weeks, she became the most enthusiastic member of the wedding-planning committee. She sent me dress ideas, floral arrangements, reception playlists, and photographs of elaborate cakes that cost more than my first car.

She insisted on being my maid of honor.

Then, almost exactly three months before the wedding, she disappeared.

Not physically. She still went to work. She still posted the occasional photograph online. She still answered our mother's calls, at least sometimes.

But the Kayla I knew seemed to have retreated somewhere I couldn't reach.

At first, I blamed stress.

Then depression.

Then myself.

Had I been too absorbed in wedding plans? Had I forgotten something important? Had I said something cruel without realizing it?

I replayed our last happy conversations until I could recite them from memory.

There was nothing.

Nothing I could explain.

Nothing that justified a sister shutting her door and begging me not to marry the man I loved.

On the evening after our takeout dinner, I opened the drawer beside my bed and took out the photograph I had kept since childhood.

It showed Kayla and me at the beach when I was twenty and she was sixteen. My hair was tangled from the wind. Her face was covered in sunscreen. We were laughing at something outside the frame, our arms wrapped around each other's shoulders.

On the back, in Kayla's handwriting, were the words she had written years ago.

No matter what happens, it's always us.

I pressed the photograph against my chest.

Then my phone lit up.

A message from an unknown number appeared on the screen.

UNKNOWN: If you love your sister, cancel the wedding. Ask Tyler what happened on November 18.

I read it once.

Then again.

November 18.

I knew the date.

It was the day Tyler had told me he was attending a conference in New York.

The day he had left our apartment before sunrise and returned shortly after midnight.

The day Kayla had called me three times, only to hang up before I could answer.

My fingers began to tremble.

I typed a reply.

WHO IS THIS?

The message showed as delivered.

No answer came.

I called the number.

It rang once before going straight to voicemail.

I sat on the edge of the bed, listening to the quiet apartment around me.

In the living room, Tyler laughed at something on television.

It was an ordinary sound. Familiar. Warm.

And suddenly, I couldn't bear the thought of hearing it again without knowing what it meant.

I walked to the doorway.

"Tyler?"

He turned toward me, remote in hand.

"Yeah?"

I almost asked him about November 18.

I almost held up my phone and demanded to know who had sent the message.

Instead, I looked at the man I was about to marry and asked the only question I could bring myself to say aloud.

"Is there anything you need to tell me?"

His smile faded.

For several seconds, he didn't move.

Then he stood, crossed the room, and wrapped his arms around me.

"No, Rachel."

He kissed my forehead.

"Nothing at all."

But over his shoulder, I saw his phone lying on the coffee table.

The screen had lit up.

One name appeared in the notification.

KAYLA.

May you like

And beneath it were five words.

She got the message. Call me.

Related Stories

Other posts