Chapter 10 - The Room They Had Already Searched

Marianne did not allow me to leave her office alone.
She called a colleague, arranged for someone to escort me to a nearby hotel, and spent the next twenty minutes making telephone calls in a voice that became colder with every conversation.
I sat in the corner with my father's letter folded in my hands.
Someone had entered his study.
Someone had searched the filing cabinet.
And someone had taken the blue folder.
I kept thinking about the reading lamp I had seen through the study window while Celeste stood over me in the rain. The lamp had been on. The room had looked untouched from outside. I had been so desperate to retrieve my father's watch that I hadn't even considered whether anyone else had already entered the house.
Now I wondered whether Celeste had thrown me out because she wanted the room to herself.
Or whether she had been trying to get me away before someone came looking.
Neither possibility made her innocent.
But they did make the situation more dangerous than I had imagined.
At eleven thirty, Marianne received confirmation that the police had secured the property temporarily while investigators documented the disturbance. No one had been arrested. No one had been identified as the person who entered the study.
Celeste had apparently told the officers that she believed the intruder was a disgruntled employee of my father’s accounting firm.
I almost laughed when Marianne relayed that information.
“My father didn't have employees who would break into his house and steal a folder,” I said. “He had colleagues. People he trusted.”
“People he trusted until he discovered something,” Marianne replied.
“You think the intruder came for the documents?”
“I think we should assume that until evidence proves otherwise.”
She closed the folder on her desk.
“I'm going to the house.”
I stood immediately.
“I'm coming with you.”
“No.”
“Marianne—”
“You have no reason to expose yourself to a potentially dangerous situation.”
“I have every reason. My father was murdered. Someone has searched his study. And you keep telling me that I need to understand what happened, but every time we get close to something, I'm told to wait somewhere safe.”
“Because you are grieving, and grief makes people mistake urgency for courage.”
I stared at her.
“Maybe. But being told to stay behind while strangers search my father's home doesn't make me feel safer. It makes me feel useless.”
For a long moment, Marianne said nothing.
Then she picked up her coat.
“You will remain with me. You will not touch anything, confront anyone, or leave my side. If the police tell us to go, we go. Agreed?”
“Yes.”
“And if I say we're leaving?”
“I'll leave.”
She looked at me as if she knew I was making a promise I might struggle to keep.
“Good. Let's go.”
The house looked smaller when we approached it in daylight.
It had always seemed enormous when I was a child. The pale stone façade, the wide front steps, the black iron railings, and the tall windows had made it feel like a place where nothing terrible could happen. My father had bought it after his divorce from my mother, when he was trying to build a quieter life. It had become the place where I spent holidays, weekends, and summers when I was old enough to drive myself there.
I knew the creak of the third stair.
I knew which kitchen cabinet held the good tea.
I knew that the upstairs hallway became unbearably cold in January because one of the windows never sealed properly.
But standing at the front gate, I felt like a stranger approaching a property I had no right to enter.
A uniformed officer stood beside the front door.
Marianne showed her identification and explained why we were there. After a brief conversation, the officer allowed us inside under the condition that we remain in the areas already cleared by investigators.
The moment I crossed the threshold, I smelled something unfamiliar.
Not smoke.
Not anything as obvious as broken glass.
It was the smell of furniture polish, cold coffee, and the faint metallic scent of a room that had been disturbed.
The hallway table was crooked. One of the framed photographs had been turned face down. A thin trail of muddy water marked the hardwood near the back entrance.
I looked toward the staircase.
My father's watch had been on the small table beside the study door for as long as I could remember. He took it off every night and placed it there before going to bed.
The table was empty.
I tried not to react.
Marianne noticed anyway.
“What is it?”
“His watch was there.”
“Was it valuable?”
“Not particularly. It was old. My grandfather gave it to him when Dad started his accounting firm.”
“Then it may have been taken for sentimental reasons, or it may simply have been overlooked by whoever searched the room.”
I looked at the empty table.
“Or they knew what it meant.”
Marianne didn't disagree.
We went upstairs.
The study door stood open.
I stopped at the threshold.
My father's desk had been pulled away from the wall. Papers covered the floor. The bottom drawer of the filing cabinet hung open, and the cabinet itself had a long scrape across one side where it had apparently been dragged.
The bookshelves had been disturbed. Several books lay open on the carpet, their pages bent back. A framed photograph of my father, my mother, and me had fallen behind a chair.
I picked it up before remembering Marianne's warning.
She gave me a brief look.
“It's all right. The officers have already documented that area.”
The photograph showed me at eight years old, sitting between my parents at a lakeside picnic. My father had one arm around my shoulders. My mother was laughing at something outside the frame.
They looked happy.
Not like a divorced couple trying to pretend.
Not like two people whose lives would eventually end in separate places on the same morning.
They looked like my parents.
I wiped the glass with my sleeve and placed the frame carefully on the desk.
“Dad kept this here,” I said.
“Did he have many photographs of your mother?”
“More than Celeste liked.”
Marianne looked toward the door.
“Did Celeste ever ask him to remove them?”
“She didn't ask. She would make comments. She said it was unhealthy to keep reminders of a previous marriage. Dad told her that my mother wasn't a mistake he needed to hide.”
I looked at the photograph.
“I think that was the last time I heard him raise his voice to her.”
Marianne moved toward the filing cabinet.
“Did your father keep financial records in this room?”
“Some. The accounting firm's main records were stored electronically and at the office. But Dad kept personal documents here. Property records. Old tax files. Anything he wanted to review without his partners seeing it.”
“Would the blue folder have been kept here?”
“Yes.”
“Where?”
I closed my eyes, trying to remember.
“He kept important documents in the top drawer of the desk. The things he was actively working on went in the left side. The things he didn't want to forget went in the right.”
I walked around the desk without touching anything.
The right drawer was open.
Its contents had been scattered across the floor.
I crouched and studied the papers.
There were insurance statements, old letters, property tax notices, and copies of trust documents. One page had been torn in half. Another had a dark shoeprint across the corner.
But I recognized the thin green divider my father used for documents that required his signature.
It lay near the desk leg.
I picked it up.
Marianne leaned over my shoulder.
“What's that?”
“Dad used these dividers for anything he planned to sign. He kept a separate stack for documents that needed someone else's signature.”
“Was there something in it?”
I opened the divider.
A single sheet of paper remained inside.
It was a photocopy of a property transfer agreement involving a warehouse on the eastern edge of the city. The address meant nothing to me at first, but the names at the bottom did.
Northbridge Holdings.
Grant Whitaker.
And Richard Bennett.
My father's signature appeared on the last page.
I stared at it.
“That isn't right.”
Marianne took the paper carefully.
“What do you mean?”
“My father would never sign a transfer agreement without a review period. He would never sign something like this with blank sections.”
She examined the page.
“Which sections?”
“The consideration amount is incomplete. There's no attached schedule listing the assets being transferred. And this witness line is blank.”
Marianne read the document again.
“Do you know whether your father signed the original?”
“I don't know. But this isn't how he worked.”
She placed the page in a protective sleeve from her briefcase.
“Then we need to find the original and compare it with the filed version.”
I looked at the other papers scattered around the desk.
“Why would someone leave this here?”
“Possibly because they were searching for a different document. Possibly because they didn't recognize its significance.”
“Or they wanted us to find it.”
Marianne looked at me.
“That is possible too. We shouldn't assume the evidence was left accidentally or deliberately until we know more.”
I stepped around the desk.
A narrow section of the wall behind the bookshelves was visible because several books had been pulled out. I remembered that section from childhood. My father had once shown me a small recessed compartment there, hidden behind a false backing panel.
It had been empty then.
“Marianne.”
She followed my gaze.
“Does that wall open?”
“I think so.”
She called the officer into the room and explained what I had noticed. He photographed the area before allowing us to examine the loose panel.
The panel slid out with a faint wooden scrape.
Behind it was a narrow cavity.
It was empty.
Except for a small rectangular impression in the dust, as though a thin object had rested there for a long time.
I stared at it.
“Dad kept something here.”
“Do you know what?”
“No.”
I leaned closer.
There was a tiny strip of blue fabric caught along the inside edge.
Marianne took a photograph before asking the officer to document it.
“Could it have come from the folder?”
“Maybe.”
She examined the cavity.
“Was your father aware that someone else knew about this compartment?”
“I don't think so.”
“Are you sure?”
I remembered something.
When I was fifteen, I had come into the study looking for a book. Celeste had been standing near the shelves, holding a cup of tea. She had asked me whether my father kept his business documents there.
I had said I didn't know.
She had smiled and told me that I was lucky not to have to worry about adult things.
At the time, I had thought she was being kind.
Now I couldn't remember whether the panel had been closed.
I told Marianne.
She wrote something in her notebook.
“Do not turn a memory into proof,” she said. “But do not discard it either.”
We searched no further. The police had to finish their work, and Marianne refused to interfere with the official investigation.
Before we left, I walked through the house one final time.
In the kitchen, Celeste's expensive coffee machine sat on the counter beside a bowl of lemons. In the living room, a new arrangement of flowers occupied the table where my father used to spread the Sunday newspaper. The house was full of small signs that someone had already begun replacing the life he had lived there.
I felt a sudden, furious urge to break something.
Instead, I put my hands in my coat pockets.
“She's acting as though nothing happened,” I whispered.
Marianne stood beside me.
“People react to fear in different ways.”
“She doesn't look afraid.”
“Then perhaps she is hiding it. Or perhaps she fears something different from what you do.”
I looked at her.
“What do you think she fears?”
Marianne glanced toward the staircase.
“Losing control.”
We were nearly at the front door when an officer called out to us.
“Ms. Vale? There is something you should see.”
He held a clear evidence bag containing a torn envelope.
My father's name was written across the front.
The flap had been ripped open, and the contents were gone.
I recognized the handwriting immediately.
It was my father's.
“Where did you find that?” I asked.
“Under the desk. It appears to have been stepped on.”
Marianne studied the envelope.
“Was there anything inside when it was recovered?”
“No. But there's a partial impression on the paper beneath it.”
He turned the bag slightly.
I could see several words pressed into the envelope's inner surface, as though someone had written on a sheet placed above it.
Most were illegible.
One phrase was clear.
Original agreement.
Marianne looked at me.
Then, from somewhere beyond the front gate, I heard the sharp sound of a car door slamming.
I turned toward the window.
A black sedan was parked across the street.
The driver was watching the house.
When he noticed me looking, he started the engine.
“Marianne,” I said.
She followed my gaze.
The sedan pulled away before the officer reached the window.
I could not see the driver's face.
But I recognized the vehicle.
May you like
It had been parked outside my father's funeral.
And it had been there the night Celeste threw me out.