talehub

Chapter 4 - The Photograph at the Bottom of the Suitcase

Brielle's apartment smelled of damp plaster, burnt toast, and the lemon cleaner her landlord used whenever he wanted to pretend the building was being maintained.

She loved it anyway.

It was small enough that she could see the front door from her bed. The kitchen consisted of a narrow counter, a two-burner stove, and a refrigerator that hummed loudly enough to drown out the neighbors' arguments. The bathroom had a crack in the ceiling shaped vaguely like the state of Illinois.

The window overlooked an alley where someone had abandoned a bicycle three winters ago.

It was the first place Brielle had ever lived where she could lock the door and know that nobody had the right to enter without her permission.

That mattered more than the peeling wallpaper.

She shut the door behind her, turned the deadbolt, and stood still.

Only then did she allow herself to shake.

Her hands trembled so violently that she had to brace herself against the kitchen counter. The adrenaline that had kept her standing on the street was gone, leaving exhaustion and pain in its place.

She looked at her reflection in the dark window.

A bandage crossed her temple. Her cheek was swollen. Her lips had split at one corner.

She looked like someone who had lost a fight.

She supposed she had.

The fact that she had survived it seemed almost beside the point.

Brielle turned on the kitchen light and examined her palm. Dr. Patel had used five stitches, then wrapped the wound in a clean dressing. Her shoulder had been badly bruised but not broken. The doctor had told her to rest, watch for symptoms of a concussion, and return immediately if she developed worsening headaches, confusion, vomiting, or unusual drowsiness.

He had also told her that she was lucky.

Brielle was beginning to dislike that word.

People had called her lucky when she survived the night her sister died.

Lucky when a distant aunt agreed to take her in.

Lucky when she found a job that paid enough to keep a roof over her head.

Lucky when she managed to leave a bad situation before it became worse.

Luck had always seemed to mean that something terrible could have happened, but hadn't happened yet.

She opened the refrigerator.

Half a carton of milk. Two eggs. A plastic container of rice. A jar of mustard.

She shut it again.

Her stomach was too unsettled to eat.

Instead, she filled a glass with water, took the pain medication the doctor had prescribed, and sat on the edge of her bed.

The yellow flower lay on the table beside her.

She had carried it home in the pocket of her uniform.

Now she took it out and laid it carefully on the windowsill.

The petals had nearly fallen off.

Brielle touched one gently.

“Your dad is terrifying,” she whispered to the empty room.

She thought of Adrian Moretti's expression when Lily had told him she had been hurt.

It hadn't been ordinary anger.

It had been something colder, more controlled, and infinitely more dangerous.

He had looked at the captured gunman as though he were already calculating the man's future in the smallest possible units.

Brielle knew enough about Chicago to understand what that meant.

She had heard stories about the Morettis since childhood. Some came from the neighborhood. Others came from people who worked in the restaurants, warehouses, and construction companies that carried their name.

The stories contradicted one another in almost every detail.

Some said Adrian had inherited his father's criminal empire and expanded it. Others said he had nearly destroyed the family organization by forcing its older members to accept rules they hated. A few insisted he was more dangerous than his father precisely because he rarely lost his temper.

Nobody agreed on much.

Except that it was unwise to make an enemy of him.

Brielle rubbed her forehead.

She had no intention of becoming part of his world.

She had already learned what happened when dangerous people took an interest in you.

Eleven years earlier, she had made that mistake once.

She wasn't going to make it again.

The photograph was hidden beneath the loose lining of her suitcase.

Brielle had sewn the lining herself with a needle borrowed from a woman at the nursing home where she'd once worked. The stitches were uneven, but they had held for years.

She rarely opened it.

Tonight, she didn't know why she did.

Perhaps the gunshot had shaken loose something she had kept buried. Perhaps Lily's frightened face had brought back too many memories. Or perhaps the sight of the yellow flower had finally broken through the wall she had spent more than a decade building.

Whatever the reason, she found herself kneeling beside the suitcase, carefully undoing the thread.

Inside was a small envelope.

Within the envelope lay a photograph, a folded newspaper clipping, and a silver-colored hair clip shaped like a butterfly.

Brielle picked up the photograph first.

Two girls stood in front of a chain-link fence covered with summer vines.

Brielle was sixteen, all elbows and awkward limbs, with a crooked smile she hadn't yet learned to hide. Her younger sister, Claire, was eleven. She had dark hair, bright eyes, and a chipped front tooth.

Claire held a yellow flower in one hand.

The same kind of flower Lily had offered Brielle that afternoon.

Brielle sat down hard on the floor.

She could hear Claire's voice as clearly as if the girl were standing beside her.

When we're grown-ups, we're going to have a garden.

We live in an apartment.

Then we'll get a house.

With what money?

We'll figure it out.

Claire had never doubted that they would figure it out.

Brielle had always admired that about her.

She had also resented it.

Claire believed in people. Brielle believed in locked doors, spare money, and never letting anyone know how much you needed them.

Their differences had seemed harmless when they were children.

By the time Claire was eleven and Brielle was sixteen, they had become a source of constant arguments.

Their mother had been dead for two years. Their father had disappeared into a cycle of drinking, apologies, and absences that left the girls learning to take care of themselves.

Brielle worked evenings at a grocery store.

Claire made dinner.

Brielle saved money.

Claire spent it on school supplies for children who couldn't afford them.

Brielle told her she was naive.

Claire told her she was scared.

They had both been right.

The last time Brielle saw her sister alive, they were arguing.

The memory arrived with such force that Brielle dropped the photograph.

She could see the narrow apartment on Ashland Avenue, the cracked kitchen tiles, the yellow light above the sink. She could hear the rain striking the window.

Claire had been standing by the front door.

“Don't go,” she'd said.

Brielle had been furious.

“I have work.”

“He said he was coming back.”

“Then let him come back. I'm not staying here to listen to you defend him.”

“You don't understand.”

“Then explain it to me!”

Claire had looked at her with frightened, exhausted eyes.

Brielle remembered the silence that followed.

Then Claire had said, very softly, “I'm scared.”

And Brielle, who had been sixteen and tired and desperate to escape the apartment, had made the worst decision of her life.

She had left.

She had told herself that Claire was being dramatic. That the man who had been visiting the apartment was probably harmless. That their argument would be forgotten by morning.

By the time Brielle returned, the ambulance was already gone.

Claire died in the hospital that night.

The official report described an accident.

Brielle had never believed it.

But she had been sixteen, without money or influence, and terrified of the questions adults asked when they wanted to know whether you had done enough to save someone.

So she had said nothing.

She had carried the guilt instead.

Eleven years.

Four thousand nights.

A thousand different versions of what she should have done.

She had tried to convince herself that one moment did not define a life.

But every time she saw someone in danger, every time a child cried, every time a woman looked frightened and alone, she was transported back to that apartment.

And every time, she remembered the sound of Claire asking her not to leave.

Brielle picked up the photograph.

“I didn't know,” she whispered.

It was the same thing she had told herself a thousand times.

It never helped.

The phone rang at 9:03 p.m.

Brielle nearly dropped it.

The number was unfamiliar.

She considered ignoring the call, then answered cautiously.

“Hello?”

“Miss Dawson?”

A woman's voice.

Calm, professional, and unmistakably accustomed to being listened to.

“Yes.”

“My name is Margaret Ellis. I represent Mr. Adrian Moretti.”

Brielle closed her eyes.

“Of course you do.”

“I hope I'm not disturbing you.”

“I'm injured, exhausted, and trying to decide whether I have enough food to make breakfast tomorrow. So, yes, a little.”

There was a brief pause.

Then Margaret laughed softly.

“I understand. I'll be concise.”

“Please.”

“Mr. Moretti would like to arrange a meeting with you tomorrow. He would also like to reimburse you for the medical expenses you incurred today.”

“No.”

“I haven't mentioned the amount.”

“You could offer me a million dollars. The answer would still be no.”

“May I ask why?”

“Because I don't want to owe him anything.”

“Mr. Moretti doesn't consider reimbursement a debt.”

“Then he can consider it whatever he likes.”

Another pause.

Margaret's tone remained polite.

“He is concerned that the men who attacked his family may attempt to contact you.”

Brielle went still.

“Why would they contact me?”

“Because you were a witness.”

“Then the police can protect me.”

“They can provide whatever protection they deem appropriate.”

“That doesn't sound very reassuring.”

“It wasn't intended to.”

Brielle rubbed her eyes.

“What does Adrian Moretti want from me?”

“To ask you some questions about the attack.”

“He can ask the police.”

“He has already spoken with them.”

“Then he has everything he needs.”

“Apparently not.”

Brielle looked at the photograph in her lap.

Something about the timing troubled her.

The attack had happened only hours ago, yet Adrian's representative was calling her at home. How had they obtained her number? Had they followed her from the hospital? Had someone given them her address?

She suddenly became aware of the darkness beyond her window.

“Who gave you my phone number?”

“Mr. Moretti's security team.”

“How did they get it?”

“Through the police statement and the information you provided at the hospital.”

Brielle hadn't given her phone number to Adrian's people.

She was certain of it.

Her stomach tightened.

“Did they also give you my address?”

“Yes.”

“Wonderful.”

“Miss Dawson, I appreciate that this is overwhelming. But I need you to understand something. The people who attacked Mr. Moretti's family were prepared to use lethal force in public. That makes you a potential witness in a serious criminal investigation.”

“I'm already aware.”

“Then please consider meeting with him.”

Brielle stared at the floor.

She wanted to refuse.

She wanted to hang up, turn off her phone, and spend the next week pretending that the entire afternoon had been a bad dream.

But she couldn't stop thinking about Lily.

The child's face had been filled with a terror that seemed too deep for a single afternoon's violence.

Someone had wanted to take that little girl.

Someone had been willing to shoot a stranger to accomplish it.

And Adrian Moretti, for all his wealth and power, had looked genuinely shaken when he reached his daughter.

Brielle understood that feeling.

She knew what it was to be haunted by the person you had failed to protect.

“Tomorrow,” she said at last. “One meeting. In a public place.”

“Mr. Moretti would prefer his office.”

“Then he can prefer it from a distance.”

Margaret paused.

“I'll relay your conditions.”

“And I am not accepting any money.”

“Understood.”

Brielle ended the call.

She remained seated for a long time, holding the phone in one hand and the photograph in the other.

Then she noticed something she had never paid attention to before.

On the back of the photograph, beneath the date Claire had written in blue ink, was a faint handwritten address.

Not their apartment.

Not their father's old house.

Another address entirely.

1847 South Ashland Avenue.

Brielle's breath caught.

That was the building where Claire had died.

Below the address were two words in handwriting that did not belong to either sister.

Ask Eleanor.

Brielle stared at them.

She knew the handwriting.

She had seen it once before, eleven years ago, on the back of an envelope left on the kitchen counter.

It belonged to a man who had visited Claire in the weeks before her death.

A man Brielle had never been able to identify.

And now, eleven years later, an elderly woman named Eleanor Whitmore had appeared in her life.

A woman whose son controlled half the criminal underworld of Chicago.

Brielle folded the photograph carefully.

She had spent eleven years believing her sister's death was a tragedy she had failed to prevent.

For the first time, she wondered whether it had been something else.

May you like

Something deliberate.

Something that had never truly ended.

Related Stories

Other posts