Chapter 2 - Six Children and a Stranger

By the time we reached home, the rain had turned the streets of Millbrook into silver ribbons.
I drove because I couldn't bear the thought of sitting still while someone else controlled where I went. Daniel rode beside me, staring through the windshield. Ethan sat in the back seat, separated from his half-brothers and sisters by an empty space that seemed larger than the entire car.
Noah and Nathan had spent the first ten minutes whispering to each other. Michael had said nothing at all. Lily had fallen asleep against the window, her cheeks still damp from crying.
The silence was unbearable.
I had imagined bringing home a boy from James's funeral, but never like this. Never a boy who carried my husband's secret in the shape of his face.
When we pulled into the driveway, Daniel was the first to speak.
"Everybody inside."
His voice sounded like James's when he was trying to keep the children safe without admitting he was frightened.
Michael frowned. "Why are you giving orders?"
"Because Mom has been standing up for everyone all day, and somebody needs to help her."
"I'm not a baby."
"I didn't say you were."
"Then stop talking to me like one."
"Enough," I said.
Both boys went quiet.
The front door opened before I reached the porch. My sister, Rachel, stood inside with Emma on her hip. Rachel had driven over that morning to watch our youngest while I attended the funeral, and she had stayed to prepare dinner for the children.
She took one look at Ethan and stopped smiling.
"Sarah?"
"I know," I said.
She shifted Emma to her other arm. "Who is this?"
I looked at Ethan.
He seemed to be shrinking inside his jacket.
"This is Ethan," I said. "He's James's son."
Rachel's mouth fell open.
Emma lifted her head from her aunt's shoulder.
"Daddy's son?"
Nobody answered.
The question was innocent, but it struck the room like a dropped plate.
I took Emma from Rachel and pressed my face against her soft hair. She smelled of strawberry shampoo and the cinnamon biscuits Rachel had baked to keep the children occupied.
"Sweetheart, why don't you go with Aunt Rachel and wash your hands? Dinner will be ready soon."
Emma studied Ethan.
"Does he have the same daddy as me?"
I closed my eyes.
"Yes."
She considered that for a moment, then nodded.
"Okay."
She slid down from my arms and followed Rachel toward the kitchen, apparently satisfied with the explanation.
I wished the rest of us could be so easily reassured.
Daniel shut the front door.
"How long have you known?" he asked Ethan.
Ethan looked at me.
"Fourteen years," he said quietly.
Daniel's face hardened. "That wasn't what I asked."
"I've known who my father was since I was little. I didn't know him the way you did. He came to see me sometimes, but he couldn't tell you about me."
"Couldn't?"
"That's what he said."
"Who told you to keep it a secret?"
"My mother."
"Convenient."
"Daniel," I warned.
He turned toward me. "Mom, you don't understand. Dad was our dad. He was the person who taught us to ride bikes, who came to every school concert, who stayed up all night when Noah had pneumonia. He was the one who told me that if I ever had children, I had to be the kind of father they could count on."
His voice broke.
"And he had another kid?"
I wanted to defend James. I wanted to explain that people could make mistakes when they were young, that the truth was complicated, that a secret did not necessarily erase twenty years of love.
But I had no answers.
"I don't know everything yet," I said.
Daniel laughed bitterly.
"Of course you don't. Nobody ever does, apparently."
He walked upstairs.
Michael followed him, slamming his bedroom door hard enough to rattle a framed photograph in the hallway.
Ethan stood beside the coat rack, his hands clasped in front of him.
"I can leave," he said.
The words were so quiet that I almost missed them.
I turned.
"Where would you go?"
"Home."
"Your mother is expecting you?"
He hesitated.
"She knows where I am."
"That wasn't my question."
He looked at the floor.
"No."
Something about that answer frightened me more than Daniel's anger.
"Then you're staying here tonight."
His head lifted sharply.
"I don't want to cause trouble."
"You haven't caused anything."
"But your family—"
"This is my family," I interrupted. "And James was your father, too."
Ethan's eyes filled.
He looked away before the tears could fall.
I led him into the kitchen, where Rachel was cutting vegetables and pretending not to listen.
"There's soup on the stove," she said, her voice unnaturally bright. "And bread in the oven."
She looked at Ethan.
"Would you like some?"
He nodded.
"Thank you."
Rachel placed a bowl in front of him. He ate slowly, holding the spoon as though he wasn't certain he was allowed to touch anything in our house.
I sat across from him.
"Tell me about your mother."
He stopped eating.
"Her name is Rebecca."
"Rebecca Hale?"
He nodded.
The name was unfamiliar, but it had appeared in James's letter. I had hoped hearing it aloud might somehow make the situation less bewildering.
It didn't.
"Does she know James was sick?"
"Yes."
"Did she visit him?"
"Sometimes."
I stared at him.
"At the hospital?"
He nodded again.
"How many times?"
"I don't know. A few."
"Did I ever see her?"
Ethan looked uncomfortable.
"Maybe."
The answer sent a cold sensation through my chest.
"Maybe?"
"My mom said you were usually with the younger kids when she visited. Or you were talking to the doctors. She said you wouldn't have noticed her."
I thought about the hospital rooms, the consultations, the days and nights when James was too exhausted to speak. I remembered strangers in the corridors, visitors who came and went, nurses introducing themselves at the beginning of their shifts.
Had Rebecca Hale stood outside his room while I slept in a chair beside his bed?
Had she watched me hold his hand?
Had she known exactly who I was?
"Did James love her?" I asked.
Ethan's spoon rested against the rim of his bowl.
"I think he did."
I swallowed.
"And did he love you?"
This time, Ethan answered without hesitation.
"Yes."
"How do you know?"
"Because he came back."
He looked at me, his expression suddenly fierce beneath his sadness.
"He didn't come as often as I wanted. He missed things. He wasn't there for everything. But he came back, even when my mom was angry with him. He taught me how to fix a bicycle. He showed me how to change a tire. He took me fishing once, and we sat on the river for almost four hours because neither of us knew how to catch anything."
A faint, painful smile touched his face.
"He said it was still a good day because we were together."
I had heard James say the same thing after a family camping trip in which everything had gone wrong. The tent had leaked, the food had burned, and a raccoon had stolen half our supplies.
Still a good day, he had declared, carrying a muddy Emma back to the car.
I pressed my fingers against my lips.
Ethan watched me carefully.
"He talked about you," he said.
I looked up.
"What?"
"He talked about you a lot."
"Why?"
"He said you were the kindest person he'd ever met. He said you made a home out of whatever you had. He said if he had met you before everything happened, he would've fallen in love with you anyway."
I felt something inside me give way.
For fourteen years, James had carried a second family, a second history, a second version of himself.
And apparently, he had carried me into that secret life, too.
Not as his wife.
Not as a partner who knew the truth.
But as an idealized woman he could praise without ever allowing me the dignity of making my own choices.
I stood abruptly.
"I need some air."
Rachel followed me onto the back porch.
The rain had stopped. Water dripped from the gutter, and the garden smelled of wet earth. James had built the wooden bench beside the flower beds himself. He had promised to repaint it that summer, before the doctors told us there would be no summer projects.
Rachel closed the door behind us.
"Sarah, look at me."
I couldn't.
"I don't know who I married."
"Yes, you do."
"No. I know the man who packed lunches, who kissed me before work, who carried our daughter through the house when she had nightmares. I know the man who sat with me while we learned he was dying."
My voice shook.
"But I don't know the man who had a son for fourteen years and let me believe I knew everything about him."
Rachel took my hand.
"People can love you and still do terrible things."
"That doesn't make it better."
"No. It doesn't."
I leaned against the railing.
"What am I supposed to tell the children?"
"The truth, as you learn it."
"And if the truth destroys everything?"
Rachel's expression softened.
"Then it was already broken in ways you couldn't see."
We stood together for a long time.
When I returned inside, Ethan had finished eating. He had washed his bowl and placed it in the sink. He was standing near the hallway, looking at the photographs on the wall.
There were pictures from every year of our marriage.
Our wedding day. Daniel's first birthday. Michael's kindergarten graduation. The twins in matching Halloween costumes. Lily missing her two front teeth. Emma asleep on James's chest.
Ethan was looking at the photograph from our twentieth anniversary.
James and I stood in front of the lake, his arm around my waist. I wore the blue dress he had bought me, and he was laughing at something just outside the frame.
Ethan stared at his father's face.
"I've never seen this picture before," he said.
I approached him.
"Do you have pictures of James?"
"A few."
"Would you like one of these?"
He looked startled.
"Really?"
I took the anniversary photograph from the wall. For a moment, I held it against my chest.
This was the man I had loved since high school. The boy who had bought me a ring before he could afford a decent car. The husband who had promised that I would never have to face the world alone.
I wanted to hate him.
Instead, I missed him so much that I could hardly breathe.
I handed the photograph to Ethan.
He held it carefully by the edges.
"Thank you," he whispered.
Upstairs, a door opened.
Daniel stood at the top of the staircase.
"Mom, can I talk to you?"
I followed him into the kitchen while Ethan remained in the hallway.
Daniel shut the door.
"I went through Dad's desk."
My heart lurched.
"Why?"
"Because I wanted to know if there was anything else."
He placed a folded piece of paper on the table.
It was a bank statement.
The account holder's name was James Carter. The date was from three weeks earlier, shortly before he had been admitted to the hospital for the last time.
I stared at the figures.
Every month for fourteen years, James had transferred money to an account bearing the name Rebecca Hale.
The amounts varied, but they were never small.
Some months, the transfers exceeded three thousand dollars.
There were additional payments marked with abbreviated descriptions: tuition, medical, housing, emergency.
I felt sick.
"Where did he get this money?"
Daniel shook his head.
"I don't know. But look at the total."
He pointed to the bottom of the page.
I read the figure once.
Then again.
The sum was more than we had spent on our first house.
More than the balance remaining on our mortgage.
More than I had ever imagined James could have sent to anyone without telling me.
"There's something else," Daniel said.
He slid a second paper across the table.
This one was a letter from our mortgage company.
I recognized the logo. We had refinanced the house two years earlier to cover some of James's treatment costs.
The letter was dated six months before his diagnosis.
It stated that our home had been used as collateral for a private loan.
I stared at the signature at the bottom.
James's.
"How much?" I whispered.
Daniel told me.
I gripped the edge of the table.
The debt was almost as large as the amount we still owed on the house.
"Did Dad borrow this money to pay for Ethan?"
"I don't know."
I looked toward the hallway, where the boy was still standing beneath our family photographs.
Then I looked down at the letter from the mortgage company.
May you like
My husband had died leaving me six children, a secret son, and a debt I had never agreed to.
And the next morning, I was supposed to unlock a box that might explain why.