talehub

Chapter 21 - THE FIRST WIFE

I read the message until the words seemed to lose their shape.

Ask Robert about the first wife.

Luke had been married before me.

I knew that.

His first marriage had ended years earlier, long before I met him. He had described it as a brief mistake with a woman who wanted more than he could give. He never spoke about her unless someone asked directly, and when they did, he offered the same polished explanation.

They had been incompatible.

They had wanted different things.

She had left.

I had accepted his account because I had no reason to question it.

Now I wondered what else he had left out.

I forwarded the messages to Detective Reed and Miriam, then took screenshots and preserved the original texts. Neither of them advised me to contact the sender.

Miriam called within minutes.

“Do you know the name of Luke's first wife?”

“Margaret. I think her name was Margaret Ellis.”

“Do you know where she lives?”

“No. I never met her. Luke said she moved out of state.”

“Did he mention whether they had a financial dispute?”

“He said they settled everything when they divorced.”

“Did he ever show you the divorce agreement?”

“No.”

Miriam made a note.

“Don't contact her through any account or number you don't trust. We'll see what can be established through lawful records.”

I stared at the message again.

“Do you think this person is trying to help me?”

“I don't know. A person can provide useful information and still have motives we don't understand. We should verify the facts independently.”

After we hung up, I called Nora into the room.

She read the message and sat down slowly.

“The first wife,” she murmured.

“I barely know anything about her.”

“Maybe that's the point.”

I looked at my sister.

“What if this happened before?”

“Then we need to find out what happened, not assume the worst.”

I nodded.

That was the difference between us now.

Before, I would have called Luke and demanded an explanation. I would have believed that if I could only make him speak honestly, I could resolve the problem.

Now, I understood that confronting someone who had lied to me might simply give him another opportunity to shape the story.

So I waited.

Two days later, Miriam called with an update.

She had located a public record confirming Luke's previous marriage to Margaret Ellis. The divorce had been finalized several years before our wedding.

The filing itself did not establish wrongdoing.

However, there had been a civil dispute concerning property and a jointly held account. The matter had been resolved through an agreement, and the publicly available records contained little detail.

“Could she have lost money?” I asked.

“We don't know. The existence of a financial dispute doesn't tell us who was at fault or what was agreed. We'll need more information.”

“Can we contact her?”

“We can attempt to reach her through appropriate channels. But I want you to prepare yourself for the possibility that she may not want to speak.”

I nodded.

A part of me hoped Margaret would answer every question.

Another part feared that she would confirm something I could barely bear to imagine.

I spent the afternoon sorting through old photographs.

Luke and I had taken hundreds of pictures during our courtship. He had always been careful to present himself well. In every image, he looked composed, affectionate, and certain of the future.

In one photograph, he stood beside me beneath a white arbor at the engagement party. His arm was wrapped around my waist, and he was smiling at the camera.

I remembered the moment.

He had leaned close to my ear and whispered, “Everyone is going to be jealous of us.”

I had laughed.

I had thought he meant our happiness.

Now I wondered whether he had meant the appearance of it.

Margaret agreed to speak with Miriam by telephone.

She did not want to meet me in person, and I understood. Miriam asked whether I would like to be present for the call. I said yes, provided Margaret was comfortable with it.

When the call began, I heard a woman's voice that sounded tired but steady.

“Ms. Hayes?”

“Yes,” I said. “Thank you for speaking with us.”

“I don't know how much I can help.”

“Anything you're willing to share would mean a great deal.”

There was a pause.

“Luke said you were asking about the money.”

My heart tightened.

“He told you about me?”

“No. Someone else contacted me. They said you were investigating the old accounts.”

Miriam interrupted gently.

“Can you tell us who contacted you?”

“I don't know the person's full name. They left a message with my former attorney, asking whether I would be willing to discuss my divorce from Luke.”

“Did they identify themselves?”

“They said they were working with a legal team. I asked for verification, and they never called back.”

Miriam asked a few questions to clarify the timeline. Then Margaret agreed to speak about her marriage.

“I was young,” she began. “Luke was charming. He made every decision sound reasonable. If I questioned something, he told me I didn't understand how the business worked.”

I closed my eyes.

“He said the same thing to me,” I whispered.

Margaret went quiet.

“Then perhaps you understand why I didn't want to discuss him for years.”

“I do.”

She took a breath.

“When we married, I had a small inheritance from my aunt. Nothing enormous, but enough to help us buy a house. Luke said it would be simpler if the money went through a business account because he was handling the mortgage paperwork.”

“Did you agree?”

“I agreed to a transfer for a specific purpose. Later, I discovered that the account had been used for other expenses. When I asked him about it, he said I had misunderstood the arrangement.”

“Did you sign a guarantee?”

A long silence followed.

“Yes.”

My stomach dropped.

“Did you know what it was?”

“I thought I did. The document was described as a temporary guarantee connected to the house. I signed several pages at once, and I didn't have independent advice.”

“Did you lose the house?”

“We sold it during the divorce. Some of the proceeds went toward settling the debt. I can't say that every financial decision was improper, because I don't have all the records anymore. But I know I was left with far less than I expected.”

I looked at Miriam.

She was listening without interrupting.

Margaret continued.

“Afterward, Luke told people I was irresponsible. He said I had mismanaged the money and that he had been forced to clean up the mess. I stopped correcting him because I was tired of explaining myself to people who had already decided what to believe.”

My throat tightened.

“I'm sorry,” I said.

“Don't be. You didn't do it.”

She paused.

“Did he hurt you?”

The question was so direct that I couldn't answer immediately.

“Yes,” I finally said. “He let his mother break my leg, and he refused to help me.”

Margaret inhaled sharply.

“He let her?”

“Yes.”

“Oh, Clover.”

For the first time, her voice cracked.

“He always needed someone else to be the cruel one. His mother could scream. His father could threaten to cut people off. Luke would stand in the middle and act as if he were the only reasonable person in the room.”

I thought of Luke's calm voice as I lay on the kitchen floor.

Leave her there. She needs to learn obedience.

I gripped the edge of the table.

Margaret went on.

“When we divorced, I thought I had escaped the worst of it. I didn't realize how much he had convinced me to doubt myself until I started a new job and found myself asking permission to spend my own salary.”

I could barely breathe.

“Did you ever hear of Northbridge Consulting Services?” Miriam asked.

“No.”

“Did you know a man named Daniel Price?”

“No.”

“Did you ever receive a letter or message from someone connected to the Hayes family about your inheritance?”

Margaret hesitated.

“There was a letter from an attorney after the divorce. It said the settlement was final and I should not reopen the matter without new evidence. I don't remember who sent it.”

“Would you be willing to look for it?”

“I can try.”

Miriam explained how Margaret could preserve any documents and share them through her attorney if she chose.

Before the call ended, Margaret spoke directly to me.

“There's something I want you to understand. I don't know what Luke has done this time. I don't know whether your circumstances are identical to mine. But if he tells you that you are confused, that you agreed to something you don't remember, or that you're ruining his life by asking questions, please don't let his certainty become your memory.”

I pressed my hand to my mouth.

“I won't.”

“I hope you get answers, Clover.”

“So do I.”

When the call ended, the room was silent.

Miriam closed her notebook.

“Margaret's account is relevant, but it is still an account of her experience. We need any records she can locate and must distinguish her allegations from established facts.”

“I understand.”

“Still, there are similarities worth investigating. The alleged guarantee, the use of inherited funds, the claim that she had agreed to the arrangement, and the way Luke responded when she questioned it.”

I looked at the photograph of Luke and me beneath the white arbor.

“Was I just another version of her?”

Miriam answered carefully.

“You are your own person, Clover. We don't yet know whether the underlying transactions were the same. But if there is a pattern, the records may help us identify it.”

I stared at the photograph.

The woman smiling beside Luke had no idea what waited for her.

I wished I could reach back through the paper and tell her to ask more questions.

To read every page.

To keep every receipt.

To remember that a man who loved her would not punish her for wanting to understand her own finances.

But I couldn't change the past.

I could only decide what to do with the truth now.

That evening, Margaret emailed Miriam a scanned copy of a document she had found in an old folder.

It was a letter from the law firm that had handled part of the financial dispute during her divorce. Most of the text concerned the settlement, but a paragraph near the bottom referred to a consulting entity involved in the transaction.

The name was partly obscured by a crease.

Northbridge.

The date was seven years earlier.

I read the scan with Miriam on a video call.

“Northbridge existed before my marriage,” I said.

“Or a company with that name did,” Miriam replied. “We need to verify whether it's the same legal entity or a predecessor with a similar name.”

“But Luke had a financial dispute with his first wife. Then he married me and money disappeared through a company with the same name.”

“Yes. That's why the corporate records matter.”

I leaned back.

A cold, familiar feeling spread through my chest.

The story I had been living inside was beginning to look less like a single betrayal and more like a machine that had been operating for years.

And if Margaret's records were genuine, the machine had a history.

Then Miriam opened the final page of the scan.

At the bottom was a handwritten annotation, almost illegible.

She enlarged it.

I read the words.

Contact R. Hayes before release.

Robert Hayes.

Again.

The man who had stayed silent while his wife hurt me.

The man who claimed he knew nothing about the note to my grandmother.

The man who had now admitted he saw money moving through Northbridge and chose not to question it.

I looked at Miriam.

“Was he involved in Margaret's divorce, too?”

“We don't know yet.”

“But his name is here.”

“Yes.”

May you like

For the first time, I understood that the next question wasn't simply whether Luke had lied to me.

It was how many people had helped him keep the lies alive.

Related Stories

Other posts