talehub

Chapter 10 - Isabella's Impossible Choice

Isabella Russo had never intended to become a kidnapper.

At least, that was what she told herself as she drove through the rain with Sophie sleeping in the back seat.

The little girl had cried for twenty minutes after leaving the mansion. She had demanded her mother, asked for Dominic, and threatened to tell Marco that Isabella was a bad person.

Eventually, exhaustion had overcome her.

Now Sophie slept with her cheek pressed against Bunny, her small body curled beneath a blanket.

Isabella glanced at her through the rearview mirror.

"I'm sorry," she whispered.

Sophie didn't wake.

The guilt was unbearable.

Six months earlier, Isabella had believed she was finally going to learn the truth about her father's death. Victor Hale had approached her with documents, photographs, and promises that seemed too precise to be invented.

He knew details about Anthony Russo that no outsider should have known.

He knew about the argument between Anthony and Vincent the night before the bombing.

He knew the name of the doctor who had signed Vincent's death certificate.

He even knew about a little girl named Sophie Carter.

Victor had told Isabella that Daniel Carter had stolen something from the Ash Circle. Something that could expose a network of corruption extending through the waterfront, the police, and several legitimate businesses.

He had claimed that Sophie remembered where the evidence was hidden.

Isabella had refused to help him at first.

Then Victor showed her a photograph of Emma.

A second photograph showed Sophie entering Dominic's mansion.

A third showed the old oak tree.

"I know where your niece is," Victor had said.

"You mean Dominic's housekeeper's daughter."

"Names are useful things, Isabella. They help us pretend people are strangers."

She had walked away from him that day.

But the threats continued.

Victor sent letters. He left messages. He appeared outside her apartment.

He told her that if Dominic discovered the truth before the evidence was recovered, the entire Russo family would be destroyed.

And then, two nights ago, he had made his final demand.

Bring Sophie to the old St. Agnes Hotel.

If Isabella refused, Victor would release the documents connecting her to Daniel's disappearance and make it appear that she had helped arrange Anthony's murder.

She had panicked.

She had called Dominic, intending to tell him everything.

But when she arrived at the mansion, she saw Emma crying in the kitchen. Sophie was sitting nearby, drawing pictures and humming the counting song.

And Isabella realized something.

Victor didn't need her to kidnap Sophie.

He needed her to make Dominic believe she had.

The distinction had seemed important when she first understood it.

It seemed meaningless now.

Because she had taken the child.

She had carried Sophie through a service passage that connected the eastern wing to an old maintenance tunnel. She had used a key that Victor had given her, believing it opened a storage room beneath the mansion.

Instead, it opened a concealed exit that had apparently been built decades earlier.

The security team hadn't seen her leave because the passage had been omitted from the modern architectural plans.

Isabella had taken Sophie to a safe house in Queens, intending to contact Dominic once she knew whether Victor was watching.

Then she had received the text.

THE GIRL IS IN YOUR CARE. BRING HER TO ST. AGNES.

The safe house was no longer safe.

She pulled into an abandoned gas station and parked beneath a broken light.

Sophie stirred.

"Mommy?"

Isabella turned around.

"No, sweetheart. It's Isabella."

Sophie's eyes opened.

For a moment, she looked confused.

Then she sat up.

"Where's Mr. Dominic?"

Isabella swallowed.

"We're going somewhere."

"Why?"

"Because I need to keep you safe."

Sophie stared at her.

"Mr. Dominic keeps me safe."

The simplicity of the statement nearly broke Isabella.

"I know."

"Then why did you take me?"

Isabella had no answer.

Sophie hugged Bunny.

"You're the lady from Daddy's house."

Isabella froze.

"What?"

"You had a blue coat."

Her hands tightened around the steering wheel.

"You remember that?"

Sophie nodded.

"You were crying."

Isabella looked away.

She had forgotten how much children noticed.

She had forgotten that Sophie had been there when she made the decision that changed everything.

"I was scared," Isabella admitted.

"Of the bad man?"

"Yes."

Sophie considered this.

"Me too."

Isabella began to cry.

She covered her face with both hands, ashamed of herself.

"I'm sorry, Sophie. I thought I was helping."

Sophie reached forward and patted her shoulder.

"It's okay."

Isabella shook her head.

"No, sweetheart. It isn't."

"Mommy says people make mistakes."

"Your mommy is right."

"She also says you have to fix them."

Isabella lowered her hands.

The child was looking at her with solemn green eyes.

"What if I can't fix this one?"

Sophie thought for a moment.

"Then you have to ask somebody bigger for help."

Isabella stared at her.

Then she laughed through her tears.

"You're very smart."

"I know."

For the first time since the kidnapping, Isabella smiled.

Then her phone rang.

Victor Hale.

She answered.

"Where are you?" he demanded.

"Somewhere safe."

"Bring the child to St. Agnes."

"I need more time."

"You have none."

"Victor, she's five years old."

"She's the daughter of a man who stole from me."

"Daniel didn't steal anything from you."

The silence on the other end was chilling.

Then Victor said, "You should have asked your father what Daniel did."

Isabella's blood turned cold.

"What does that mean?"

"Your father wasn't the man you remember."

The call ended.

Isabella stared at the phone.

Sophie had gone quiet.

"Who was that?" she asked.

Isabella put the phone down.

"A bad man."

Sophie nodded.

"Does he have the orange watch?"

Isabella slowly turned.

"How do you know about the watch?"

Sophie touched the side of her neck.

"Daddy said the man with the orange watch made everybody lie."

Isabella felt the world tilt.

She looked toward the rearview mirror.

A black SUV had pulled into the gas station.

Its headlights illuminated the back seat.

Two men stepped out.

One wore a dark coat.

The other carried a small silver case.

Isabella recognized the watch on the first man's wrist.

The orange emblem gleamed beneath the streetlight.

She locked the doors.

Sophie sat very still.

"Isabella?"

"Yes, sweetheart?"

"That's the bad man."

The man in the dark coat smiled and approached the driver's window.

He tapped the glass twice.

Then he held up a photograph.

It showed Dominic Russo standing outside the St. Agnes Hotel.

On the back, in black ink, were five words.

BRING THE GIRL. COME ALONE.

Isabella stared at it.

The man smiled again.

"Time to make a decision, Miss Russo."

And behind him, a second vehicle turned into the gas station.

This one carried Dominic's security insignia.

Isabella had no idea whether the men approaching her were there to save her or silence her.

May you like

But she knew one thing.

The moment she opened the door, she would be choosing which side of the war she wanted to survive.

Related Stories

Other posts