talehub

Chapter 9 - January Fourteenth

Kayla didn't sleep.

At 2:13 a.m., she was still sitting at Dana's kitchen table with the photograph spread before her, the old letter beside it, and the name Margaret Ellis written on a sheet of bakery stationery.

Outside, snow slid from the roof in soft, irregular bursts. A refrigerator hummed in the next room. Somewhere upstairs, Dana moved across the floor, then went quiet.

Everything else seemed to have stopped.

Kayla picked up the photograph again.

Her father looked impossibly young. He wore the same confident expression she remembered from school ceremonies, the same slightly raised chin that suggested he was accustomed to being listened to. Walt stood beside him, smiling with the easy warmth of someone who had never learned to disguise his feelings.

The girl between them was the person Kayla couldn't stop looking at.

She appeared to be sixteen or seventeen. Her dark hair fell past her shoulders, and she wore a heavy winter coat with a school emblem embroidered over the pocket. One hand rested on the snowplow's yellow fender. The other was tucked into her sleeve.

She was smiling.

Not a polite smile for a photograph.

A real one.

Kayla turned the picture over.

January 14, 2000.

Some people remember the road you tried to bury.

She had read the words so many times that they no longer looked like handwriting. They looked like a warning.

At the bottom of the envelope, beneath the letter signed by Daniel Mercer, she had found a photocopied document with several lines blacked out. The heading identified it as a school incident summary. Most of the details were missing, but the date was visible.

January 14, 2000.

The same day as the photograph.

The same date Margaret Ellis had been asked to explain.

Kayla opened her laptop and searched for the former counselor.

The first result was an archived North Ridge school newsletter from twelve years earlier. Margaret Ellis had been recognized for twenty years of service to the district. Beneath the photograph, a short paragraph described her as a dedicated counselor who had helped thousands of students navigate academic pressure, family difficulties, and personal crises.

Another result showed that she had retired eight years ago.

A third listed an address in a neighboring town, along with a public telephone number.

Kayla copied the number into her phone.

Then she hesitated.

What if Margaret refused to speak to her? What if the documents had been taken out of context? What if her father had written the letter because someone was spreading a false accusation, and Walt had misunderstood what happened?

She didn't want to become the person who believed the worst simply because the worst made a more compelling story.

Her father had hurt her. That was undeniable.

But hurt wasn't proof of a separate allegation.

She needed to know what had happened before deciding what the evidence meant.

Kayla picked up her phone and called Dana.

The call went to voicemail.

She sent a message instead.

Kayla: I think I need to speak with Margaret Ellis. Do you know if Walt is awake?

A few minutes later, Dana appeared at the kitchen doorway wearing flannel pajamas and a thick cardigan.

"You're still up."

"So are you."

"I was making sure you hadn't decided to drive to Margaret's house at three in the morning."

Kayla gave her a tired smile.

"I wasn't going to do that."

"Good. Because I would have hidden your keys."

Dana pulled out a chair and sat beside her.

"Tell me what you're thinking."

Kayla pushed the photograph toward her.

"I don't want to assume my father did something wrong just because Walt kept these documents. I don't even know whether the letter is connected to Emily Foster."

"That's reasonable."

"But I also don't want to ignore it."

"That's reasonable, too."

Kayla looked at the old school incident summary.

"The dates match. The photograph was taken on the same day the incident was recorded. My father wrote a letter asking Walt to stop raising questions. Then, years later, a student made a complaint that may have been handled improperly."

She paused.

"What if this is the same thing happening again?"

Dana folded her hands.

"Then we find out what can be verified. We don't have to decide the ending before we understand the beginning."

Kayla looked at her.

"How do you stay so calm?"

"I own a bakery. If I panic every time something goes wrong, the bread burns."

Despite herself, Kayla laughed.

The sound surprised her.

It was the first genuine laugh she'd managed since the night of the blizzard.

Dana smiled.

"There she is."

The moment passed quickly, but it mattered. Kayla had begun to feel as if her life had narrowed to a collection of threats, documents, and conversations she was afraid to have. The small laugh reminded her that there was still a world outside her father's shadow.

Dana glanced at the clock.

"It's almost morning. Call Margaret after eight. And before you do anything else, I want you to make copies of everything."

"I already photographed the documents."

"Good. Keep the originals safe, and don't send them to strangers. If they contain student information, we need to be especially careful."

Kayla nodded.

She knew enough about medical privacy to understand that sensitive information required care even when the intention was good. A student's history was not public property simply because adults had mishandled it.

At 7:58 a.m., Kayla called the number listed for Margaret Ellis.

A woman answered after the fourth ring.

"Hello?"

"Mrs. Ellis? My name is Kayla Mercer. I'm Daniel Mercer's daughter."

Silence.

It lasted only two seconds, but Kayla felt it.

"How did you get this number?" Margaret asked.

"I found it in a public directory. I'm sorry if this is an inconvenient time."

"What do you want?"

Kayla looked at the photograph.

"I have a letter that my father wrote to Walt, a former county snowplow driver. The letter refers to an incident involving a girl and is dated around January 2000. There's also a photograph of my father and Walt standing with a teenage girl on that date."

Margaret didn't speak.

Kayla continued carefully.

"I was also told there may have been a complaint involving a student named Emily Foster last fall. I don't know whether the two things are connected. I don't want to make accusations. I just want to understand what happened."

A soft sound came through the line.

It might have been a sigh.

Or a chair being moved.

"Where did you get those papers?" Margaret asked.

"From Walt's daughter."

"Does Walt still have them?"

"I believe so. He asked Dana to give them to me."

Another silence.

Then Margaret said, "Your father told me you were a nurse."

Kayla's stomach tightened.

"When did you speak to him?"

"Not recently."

"Then how do you know?"

"Because he used to talk about you."

Kayla didn't know what to say.

Margaret's voice grew quieter.

"I cannot discuss a student's private records over the telephone. I hope you understand that."

"I do."

"And I will not make allegations about your father based on old paperwork I haven't seen."

"I wouldn't ask you to."

"But if you have a genuine concern about how a school complaint was handled, there are formal channels. You should use them."

"I have contacted the district."

"Then let the process work."

Kayla glanced at the envelope.

"Mrs. Ellis, may I ask one question?"

"You may."

"Why did you become quiet when I mentioned January 2000?"

The line remained silent for several seconds.

Then Margaret answered.

"Because January 14 was the day I learned that a school could protect its reputation more carefully than it protected a frightened child."

Kayla felt the words settle into her chest.

"Was my father involved?"

"I will not answer that without knowing exactly what documents you have and who else has seen them."

"Would you be willing to meet with me?"

Margaret exhaled.

"I don't know."

"Please."

The word escaped before Kayla could stop it.

She closed her eyes, embarrassed by the desperation in her voice.

"I'm not trying to ruin his life," she said. "I just need to know whether the person who taught me that rules are rules believed those rules applied to him, too."

For a long moment, Margaret said nothing.

Then she gave Kayla an address.

"Come tomorrow at ten. Alone, please. Bring copies of the documents, not the originals."

Kayla wrote it down.

"Thank you."

"One more thing."

"Yes?"

"Do not tell your father that we're meeting."

The call ended.

Kayla stared at the phone.

She had expected Margaret to refuse.

Instead, the retired counselor had agreed to meet her—and had specifically warned her not to tell Daniel.

Dana appeared behind her with two mugs of coffee.

"How did it go?"

"She agreed to meet me tomorrow."

"That's good."

"She said January 14 was the day she learned a school could protect its reputation more carefully than a frightened child."

Dana's expression changed.

"Those were her exact words?"

Kayla nodded.

Dana placed the coffee on the table.

"Then whatever happened, she remembers it."

Kayla looked again at the photograph.

The girl in the middle still seemed to be smiling.

But now Kayla noticed something she hadn't seen before.

The girl was wearing a silver bracelet around her right wrist.

A narrow band with a tiny engraved star.

Kayla zoomed in on the image.

The photograph was grainy, and the bracelet was barely visible. Still, she could make out the shape of the star.

She thought of the school incident summary, the letter, and the threat she had received after asking about Emily Foster.

Then she opened the photograph's digital copy and enlarged the date.

January 14, 2000.

For the first time, she wondered whether the date mattered for another reason.

Her father had been a teacher then.

Walt had been a county snowplow driver.

Margaret had been a counselor.

And somewhere in the middle stood a girl whose name nobody had yet told Kayla.

She saved the image in a new folder.

The folder's title was simple.

JANUARY 14.

Then she added one sentence to the notes beneath it.

Find out who the girl was before deciding what the photograph proves.

May you like

It was the first rule she had written for herself.

And unlike the rules her father had given her, this one was designed to protect the truth.

Related Stories

Other posts