talehub

Chapter 6 - The Witness Who Was Afraid

I didn't drive straight to Sofia Alvarez's apartment.

I wanted to.

Every instinct I had told me to find the witness, hear what she knew, and determine whether the two incidents were connected.

But instinct was not the same as judgment.

Sofia had already told me someone had threatened her. If I arrived unexpectedly, I could frighten her further, expose her to additional danger, or give whoever was watching her another reason to interfere.

So I asked her one question.

"Are you safe right now?"

"I think so."

"That's not quite an answer."

"I'm at work. I'm in the back office, and my manager is here."

"Good. Don't go home alone. Don't confront the man who threatened you. And don't delete anything related to what happened."

She was quiet.

Then she asked, "Are you going to tell the police?"

"Yes, but I want you to have control over what happens next. I'll ask Officer Brooks to contact you through a safe method. You don't have to meet with me if you don't feel comfortable."

Another silence followed.

Finally, she whispered, "I don't want anybody else to get hurt."

"Neither do I."

She gave me the name of the restaurant where she worked and the approximate time her shift ended.

I promised to contact the officer and ended the call.

Then I sat in my truck and stared at the steering wheel.

Sofia had heard the argument.

She had been threatened.

And somebody had asked her about Caleb Pike.

The same Caleb who had left me a message six years ago.

The same Caleb whose father had just admitted giving Victor Hale an old radio after the funeral.

I started the engine.

On the way home, I called Officer Brooks and explained what Sofia had told me. I gave him her contact information, with her permission, and asked him to arrange a safe way for her to speak with investigators.

He didn't promise a quick result.

He didn't tell me that everything would be fine.

He simply said he would follow up.

That was enough.

When I reached home, Elaine was sitting beside Marcy on the couch. A cup of tea rested on the coffee table, untouched.

Marcy looked up when I entered.

"Where have you been?"

"Talking to Ray Pike."

She frowned.

"Who?"

"He's the coach at Ironclad. His son served in the Marines. I trained him years ago."

I sat in the chair opposite her.

"His son died six years ago. Before he died, he was investigating something connected to Victor Hale."

Marcy's face went pale.

"Dad, please don't."

"I'm not going to do anything reckless."

"That's what everybody says before something terrible happens."

Elaine placed a hand on her shoulder.

"Let him explain, sweetheart."

I told them about the email, the recording, and Ray's old radio.

I left out the more speculative details. I didn't want to make the situation sound more certain than it was.

When I finished, Marcy stared at me.

"So this has nothing to do with me?"

"I don't know."

She shook her head.

"I don't want to be the reason somebody else gets hurt."

"You're not responsible for what Victor Hale may have done six years ago. And you're not responsible for Dustin's decisions."

"But if he thinks you're investigating his uncle because of me—"

"Then we'll make sure the police understand what's happening."

She looked toward the window.

"What if he comes here?"

Elaine moved closer.

"Then we call the police. We don't open the door, and we don't confront him."

Marcy nodded, but I could see she was struggling to believe us.

Fear had become part of her daily life. It had taught her to anticipate danger, to interpret every silence as a warning, and to assume that the people who threatened her would eventually find a way to carry out their threats.

I couldn't undo that in a morning.

I could only keep showing her that she wasn't alone.

At noon, Officer Brooks called back.

He had spoken with Sofia.

She was willing to provide a statement, but she was frightened and wanted to understand what protections might be available to her before agreeing to anything further.

I told him I understood.

He also informed me that the department would document the threatening message sent to Elaine and review whether it could be connected to other reports.

Then he asked whether I had any evidence directly linking Victor Hale to the photograph.

I told him I didn't.

"That's important," he said. "Don't let suspicion become certainty before we have the facts."

"I won't."

After the call, I returned to the garage.

Ray had agreed to bring Caleb's belongings later that afternoon, and I wanted to prepare a clean workspace.

I cleared a section of the workbench and set out a notebook, a laptop, and a small external drive.

As I worked, I kept thinking about Sofia's words.

He asked me whether I had seen what happened to Caleb Pike.

Why would somebody investigating Marcy's injuries care about a six-year-old death?

Perhaps it was a coincidence.

Perhaps the man had asked Sofia about Caleb because he knew she had information unrelated to Dustin.

Or perhaps someone had discovered that an old mystery was about to be reopened and was trying to determine who had heard what.

I couldn't answer those questions yet.

At 3:40 p.m., Ray arrived carrying a cardboard box.

He set it on the workbench.

"Everything I could find," he said.

Inside were three notebooks, a battered laptop, a stack of printed emails, and a small envelope containing photographs.

I handled each item carefully.

The notebooks contained training notes, personal reminders, and fragments of conversations. Some pages were mundane. Others were marked with dates and initials that meant nothing to me.

The laptop was old but intact.

I powered it on.

It took several minutes to start.

When the desktop appeared, I found a folder labeled WORK and another labeled PERSONAL.

The work folder contained training schedules, equipment lists, and documents related to private security contracts.

Several files were password-protected.

I didn't attempt to break into anything I wasn't authorized to access. Ray had brought the laptop to me with the intention of helping us understand Caleb's notes, but that didn't make every document mine to open.

Instead, I examined the unprotected files and wrote down the names of the companies that appeared most frequently.

One name stood out.

Northstar Protective Services.

I had heard of the company. It provided security training, executive protection, and risk management services to private clients.

Another name appeared in a spreadsheet.

Hale Strategic Consulting.

The spreadsheet listed payments made to several subcontractors. Most entries appeared ordinary. Others had incomplete descriptions, missing reference numbers, or amounts that did not match the accompanying invoices.

I studied the dates.

Some of the irregular entries occurred in the weeks before Caleb died.

Others continued afterward.

Ray leaned over my shoulder.

"Is that Victor's company?"

"It may be connected to him. I need to verify the ownership records before I can say anything more."

I copied the relevant filenames into my notebook.

Then I found a document titled FINAL ACCOUNTING NOTES.

It contained a series of short entries, most of them written in Caleb's terse style.

Invoice 1147: duplicate equipment charge.

Invoice 1192: recipient not listed.

Transfer 203: authorization missing.

Near the bottom was another line.

The account balances only if the missing payment is ignored.

I read it twice.

Then I remembered the note from Ray's photograph.

The truth isn't in the account. It's in the gap.

"Ray, did Caleb ever mention a missing payment?"

He shook his head.

"Not to me."

I continued reading.

The document referred to a transfer made through a company whose name had been abbreviated to RBC.

A second entry mentioned a storage facility.

A third listed a date and a series of numbers that might have been an invoice reference.

None of it proved wrongdoing.

Accounting records could be incomplete for innocent reasons. A payment could be delayed, a reference number could be mistyped, and an invoice could be duplicated without criminal intent.

But Caleb had apparently believed the inconsistencies mattered.

I wrote down the information and closed the document.

"Do you know where he worked before he died?" I asked.

Ray named a small office complex near the airport.

"He was consulting for Northstar. They had a training contract with a private company that supplied equipment to several government agencies."

"Do you remember who supervised him?"

"A man named Daniel Cross."

I looked up.

"Daniel Cross?"

"Yes. Why?"

I had heard the name before, though I couldn't immediately place it.

Then I remembered a newspaper article about a former police administrator who had left public service and joined a private security firm.

The article had described Cross as a respected professional with decades of experience in law enforcement and emergency management.

I wrote down his name.

"Did Caleb trust him?"

Ray thought about it.

"At first, yes. He said Cross was smart and knew how the system worked. Later, he stopped mentioning him."

"Did he say why?"

"No."

I turned back to the laptop.

There were more files to examine, but I didn't want to draw conclusions from fragments.

Instead, I made a list of questions.

Who had authorized the irregular payments?

What was the missing transfer?

Why had Caleb believed the official account of his death was inaccurate?

And where was the recording?

As I wrote, my phone vibrated.

A message had arrived from an unknown number.

You should stop asking questions about a dead Marine.

I stared at the screen.

A second message appeared.

Your daughter has already suffered enough.

Ray read over my shoulder.

His face hardened.

"That's Victor."

"How do you know?"

"Because that's exactly how he talks."

I put the phone down.

"That isn't proof."

"No," Ray admitted. "It isn't."

For a moment, I respected him more than I had before. He was frightened, grieving, and angry, but he was still willing to acknowledge the difference between what he suspected and what he knew.

Then another message appeared.

This one contained an image.

It showed the front of our house.

The photograph had been taken from a different angle than the previous one, this time from the sidewalk near our mailbox.

At the bottom was a sentence.

Ask your wife what she saw six years ago.

I looked up.

Ray had gone completely still.

"What does that mean?" I asked.

He shook his head.

"I don't know."

May you like

But his face told me that he had an idea.

And when I asked him what he wasn't telling me, he looked away.

Related Stories

Other posts