talehub

Chapter 3 - The Cold Case of Nursery Three

The next morning broke clear and cold, sunlight sparkling off the rain-soaked trees outside Eleanor’s home.

In the attic, surrounded by dusty boxes and forgotten furniture, Eleanor sat on the floor with an old cedar chest open before her. Inside were the things she had tried so hard to bury: a pair of tiny knitted yellow booties, an unopened package of newborn diapers, and a silver-framed ultrasound photo dated ten years prior.

At the bottom of the chest lay a manila folder marked St. Jude Memorial - October 14.

She opened the folder with shaking fingers. Inside was the official death certificate of "Boy Vance," stamped by the County Registrar, declaring the cause of death as Acute Neonatal Cardiac Arrest. Signed: Arthur Sterling, M.D.

There was also a letter from the hospital's charitable foundation, offering condolences and confirming that the "remains had been respectfully cremated according to protocol."

Eleanor pressed her hand against her mouth, a silent sob escaping her lips. Ten years she had carried the crushing weight of a mother’s guilt, believing her body had failed her child, believing he was ashes in an urn she had buried in the family plot.

A quiet step sounded on the wooden stairs. Emily appeared in the doorway, holding a small plate with two slices of toast.

“He’s awake,” Emily said quietly, stepping into the attic. “He was sitting on the floor in his room, just looking at the wall. I offered him some juice, but he’s really quiet.”

Eleanor wiped her cheeks and stood up, placing the folder back into her lap. “Thank you, sweetie. How are you feeling about all of this?”

Emily sat down on an old trunk, looking down at her boots. “It’s weird,” she admitted honestly. “I’ve been your only kid my whole life. You always talked about Thomas like an angel in the sky. Now he’s downstairs eating cereal, and he smells like wet rain.”

Eleanor walked over and knelt beside her daughter, wrapping an arm around her waist. “I know it’s a lot, Emily. And I know it’s scary. But he’s your brother. He’s suffered so much, and he needs us.”

“I know,” Emily whispered, looking at the ultrasound photo in Eleanor’s hands. “I don't hate him, Mom. I just… I want to make sure you still love me too.”

“Oh, baby,” Eleanor pulled Emily into a tight hug, kissing her hair. “I love you with all my heart. Having Thomas back doesn't take an inch of my love away from you. It just makes our family whole again.”

Downstairs in the kitchen, Marcus was on his encrypted work phone, pacing back and forth across the hardwood floor.

“I don't care if it’s Saturday, Sarah,” Marcus said into the receiver, his tone authoritative. “Run a confidential check on a woman named Margaret—first name only for now, estimated age sixty to sixty-five, lived in the industrial district near the old river bend. I need any death records filed in the county over the last thirty days.”

He paused, listening to his assistant’s reply, then lowered his voice. “And Sarah… do not log this in the department database. Use a secure server. If anyone asks, you’re pulling background for an old probate case.”

He hung up as Eleanor and Emily walked down the stairs.

“Did you find anything?” Eleanor asked.

“My assistant is searching for Margaret’s death certificate,” Marcus replied, rubbing his weary eyes. “If we can locate her actual identity, we can track down where she worked ten years ago. If she was a nurse or an orderly at St. Jude’s, that’s our smoking gun.”

Thomas stepped out from the living room, holding the faded plush bear Emily had given him earlier. He looked cleaner now, his hair washed and brushed, though he still walked with the tentative, cautious gait of someone expecting a blow.

“Thomas,” Marcus said gently, stepping toward him. “Do you remember anything else about Margaret’s house? Did she have visitors? Did anyone ever drop off money or supplies?”

Thomas thought for a moment, his brows furrowing in concentration.

“A man came,” Thomas said slowly. “Once a month. Late at night. He drove a dark car with tinted glass. He never came inside, but Margaret would go out to the driveway and talk to him. They would fight.”

“Did you ever see his face?” Eleanor asked, stepping closer.

“Only once,” Thomas whispered, looking up at Eleanor. “In the headlights. He was an old man with white hair and gold glasses. He had a shiny pin on his suit jacket shaped like a star.”

Eleanor’s blood ran cold.

May you like

The caduceus pin shaped like a star—the exclusive emblem awarded to the Board of Trustees at St. Jude Memorial Hospital.

Dr. Arthur Sterling wore that gold pin on the lapel of his lab coat every single day.

Related Stories

Other posts