talehub

Chapter 8 - The Lawsuit

At 10:00 AM on Thursday morning, the offices of Bowen & Associates on North Main Street in downtown Dayton were quiet and sunlit.

Margaret Bowen sat behind a dark cherrywood desk. She was sixty-two, with silver-grey hair cut into a sharp bob, wearing a navy blazer and wire-rimmed glasses. On her desk sat a fresh legal backing folder containing twenty pages of drafted pleadings.

Drew and Grandma Ruth sat in the two leather armchairs opposite her.

"We filed the complaint thirty minutes ago in the Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas," Margaret said, sliding a copy of the filing across the desk to Drew.

The top of the first page read:

IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS

MONTGOMERY COUNTY, OHIO

DREW E. COLLINS,

Plaintiff,

v. CASE NO. 2026-CV-04112

ARTHUR M. COLLINS, individually and as Custodian,

BRENDA L. COLLINS, and TYLER A. COLLINS,

Defendants.

COMPLAINT FOR BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY, CONVERSION, UNJUST ENRICHMENT, AND CONSPIRACY

Drew scanned the bold headings down the page:

Count I: Breach of Fiduciary Duty under R.C. 5814.01 et seq. (against Defendant Arthur Collins)

Count II: Conversion of Custodial Property (against all Defendants)

Count III: Unjust Enrichment and Constructive Trust over Real Property located at 1412 Maplewood Dr. (against Defendant Tyler Collins)

Count IV: Civil Conspiracy (against Defendants Brenda and Arthur Collins)

"What does 'Constructive Trust' mean?" Drew asked, pointing to Count III.

Margaret leaned forward, resting her forearms on the desk. "It means we are asking the court to place an immediate legal lis pendens lien on Tyler’s house in Centerville. Since the down payment on that property was paid directly with stolen custodial funds, Tyler does not legally own that equity—you do. The court can order the property sold at auction to satisfy the judgment and return your $187,412.08, plus statutory interest and legal fees."

"How long will that take?" Ruth asked.

"Normally, a civil fraud case like this could drag out for twelve to eighteen months," Margaret replied. "However, given the broadcast media attention and the absolute lack of any legal defense—Arthur signed the checks, and the wire trail leads directly to the title company—their attorney is going to tell them to settle immediately."

"Who is their attorney?" Ruth inquired.

"Donald Vance," Margaret said with a faint, tight smile. "He’s an old friend of mine. He called me twenty minutes ago after he was served with the summons."

"What did he say?" Drew asked.

Margaret picked up a yellow notepad. "Donald said his clients are terrified. The story has been picked up by national news outlets—Good Morning America called his office an hour ago. Brenda lost her position as chair of the beautification committee this morning, and Arthur’s union representative called him in to discuss reputational ethics policies at the plant."

Margaret looked directly into Drew’s eyes.

"Donald offered an initial settlement proposal," Margaret continued. "They will agree to sign over the deed to Tyler’s house voluntarily so it can be listed for immediate sale, provided you drop the personal fraud charges against Brenda and Arthur and issue a joint public statement saying the matter has been amicably resolved."

Drew looked at Grandma Ruth.

Ruth’s expression was unreadable. "It's your decision, Drew. This is your life."

Drew thought about the burning sting on her cheek from her mother’s hand. She thought about her father staring at the oil stain on the garage floor. She thought about Tyler shouting at the camera, holding a box of ceiling fans bought with her future.

"Tell Donald Vance no," Drew said.

Margaret raised an eyebrow. "No to the public statement?"

"No to all of it," Drew said, her voice hard as steel. "They don't get a quiet settlement. They sell the house, they return every dollar plus interest, they pay your legal fees, and they apologize to Grandma Ruth in writing. Otherwise, we go to trial."

May you like

Margaret smiled—a slow, genuine smile of professional appreciation.

"I will relay your terms to Mr. Vance," Margaret said. "He has twenty-four hours to accept."

Related Stories

Other posts