talehub

Chapter 6 - The Deposition

Three weeks later.

I was discharged from St. Jude Memorial into Maya’s care. My physical wounds were far from healed; the third-degree burns across my chest and abdomen required daily dressing changes, heavy prescription ointments, and compression garments that felt tight and uncomfortable under my clothes. Walking took immense effort, and every movement of my torso sent sharp shoots of pulled, healing tissue pain through my frame.

But mentally, the woman who had entered that hospital three weeks ago was gone completely.

Maya had brought me to her home—a secure, high-rise condominium in the heart of the downtown legal district, equipped with twenty-four-hour desk security, private elevator access, and floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the river. For the first two weeks, I barely slept, waking up in cold sweats every time the wind rattled the windowpanes, convinced that Luke had somehow escaped county jail and was standing in the doorway with a pot of boiling water.

Maya stayed right by my side. She cooked warm meals, helped me change my difficult dressings without a single word of complaint, and sat with me on the balcony in the quiet evenings, reminding me with every breath that I was safe, free, and protected.

On a crisp Tuesday morning in mid-November, we walked into the grand, wood-paneled conference room on the fourteenth floor of the State Attorney's Office for Luke’s formal pre-trial deposition.

Luke was already seated across the long mahogany table.

He looked horrific.

Without his tailored suits, his hair products, and his carefully curated skincare routine, the thirty-six-year-old high-flying accountant looked gaunt, hollowed-out, and distinctly pathetic. He was wearing an orange county jail jumpsuit, heavy steel handcuffs chained around his waist, and leg shackles that clinked loudly against the carpet whenever he shifted his weight.

Beside him sat his lead defense attorney—a high-priced criminal lawyer named Arthur Sterling, who looked thoroughly miserable to be in the room.

When Luke looked up and saw me walk in—dressed in a crisp white silk blouse, dark trousers, and standing tall beside Maya—his eyes lit up with a flash of his old, psychotic arrogance.

"Caroline," Luke said, his voice raspy from weeks in jail, forcing a sickly sweet, manipulative smile onto his face. "Thank God. Look at you... you look so much better. Tell these people... tell them this is all a massive mistake. We can fix this, sweetie. Just tell them—"

"Shut your mouth, Luke," Maya said, her voice like a dropping guillotine as she pulled out my leather chair and helped me sit down. "You don't speak to my client unless asked a direct question by the State Attorney. If you open your mouth out of turn again, I will add three additional counts of witness intimidation to your indictment before lunch."

Arthur Sterling leaned over, grabbing Luke’s orange sleeve and whispering fiercely into his ear: "Shut up, Luke! Do not say another word!"

Luke snapped his mouth shut, his jaw flexing violently as he glared across the table at me. His hands twitched in his iron cuffs, the metal rattling against the mahogany wood.

Assistant District Attorney Ellison sat at the head of the table, tapping his pen against a yellow legal pad. Beside him sat a court reporter, her fingers resting on the keys of her stenotype machine.

"We are on the record in the matter of State of Pennsylvania versus Lucas Allen Morrison," Ellison announced calmly. "Present for the prosecution: ADA Ellison, Ms. Caroline Morrison, and her counsel, Ms. Maya Lin. Present for the defense: Mr. Arthur Sterling and the defendant, Lucas Morrison."

Ellison turned his sharp eyes toward Luke.

"Mr. Morrison," Ellison began, leaning forward. "On the evening of October 14th, emergency services were dispatched to your residence at 412 Oakridge Lane. Medical personnel discovered your wife suffering from extensive third-degree thermal injuries across twenty-four percent of her body surface area."

Luke cleared his throat, trying to regain his polished, corporate tone. "As I told the police, it was an accident. My wife was careless near the stove—"

"Mr. Morrison," Ellison interrupted, tapping a thick blue folder on the table. "We have obtained sworn affidavits from three independent forensic pathologists, including the Chief Medical Examiner of the state. All three experts have concluded unanimously that the burn patterns on your wife’s body could only have been caused by a deliberate, top-down pour originating from an individual standing over her while she was on her knees or cowering."

Luke’s face twitched. "They're wrong. It was a chaotic moment—"

"Furthermore," Ellison continued smoothly, turning a page. "We have executed a search warrant on your personal cell phone and home computer network. Forensic technicians recovered seventeen deleted internet search queries performed on your private browser over the six weeks prior to the incident."

Ellison picked up a sheet of paper and read the printed text aloud into the court record:

"'How much boiling water causes permanent skin destruction?'" "'Can high heat induce miscarriage in first trimester?'" "'How to explain kitchen scald injuries to emergency room staff without raising suspicion.'"

A sickening, heavy silence descended over the room.

I felt the blood drain from my face as I heard those words read aloud. I looked across the table at Luke.

He didn't look at me. He looked down at the mahogany table, his face devoid of all expression, his hands perfectly still inside his steel cuffs.

Beside him, his attorney, Arthur Sterling, slowly closed his eyes, leaning his forehead against his palm in sheer, hopeless defeat.

"Mr. Morrison," Ellison said softly, leaning over the table. "Your trial is set to begin in six weeks. The evidence against you includes forensic burn analysis, computer search histories, bank records showing systemic financial theft, and the medical records of two deceased fetuses whose deaths were caused by blunt force abdominal trauma."

Ellison paused, letting the weight of the words settle in the cold room.

"The State of Pennsylvania is offering you one single opportunity to avoid spending the rest of your natural life in a maximum-security prison," Ellison stated. "You will plead guilty to Attempted First-Degree Murder and two counts of Aggravated Fetal Homicide. You will surrender all claim to all marital assets, real estate, and financial holdings to Caroline Morrison. And you will serve a mandatory minimum sentence of forty-five years without the possibility of parole."

"Forty-five years?!" Luke shrieked, jumping up from his chair, his leg shackles clattering violently against the table legs. "That's a life sentence! I'm thirty-six years old!"

"Then I suggest you take your chances with a jury, Mr. Morrison," Maya said calmly, leaning forward across the table and looking him straight in his bloodshot eyes. "Because if we go to trial, I will personally stand in front of twelve citizens of this county and show them every photograph of my sister’s burned flesh. I will show them every document proving you stole millions from her. And I will make sure the judge gives you consecutive life sentences without a single breath of mercy."

Luke stared at Maya, then looked at me.

For five years, I had shrunk away from his gaze. I had looked at the floor. I had trembled. I had apologized for things I never did.

This time, I didn't look away.

I stared straight into his dark, empty eyes, holding his gaze with absolute, unyielding coldness.

May you like

"Sign the paper, Luke," I said, my voice echoing off the wood panels, steady, strong, and clear. "Sign the paper, or spend the rest of your life dying in a cell."

Luke looked down at the plea agreement sitting on the table before him. His hands shook so violently the handcuffs clinked like small bells. Slowly, painfully, he reached out his hand, took the black pen from his attorney's trembling fingers, and pressed the tip to the signature line.

Related Stories

Other posts