Chapter 17 - TWO BOYS, ONE NAME

The photograph remained on the hospital table for eleven minutes before anyone spoke.
Sarah knew because she counted every second.
Eleven minutes of staring at two newborn babies.
Eleven minutes of trying to understand how the man she had once trusted with her entire life could have constructed such an elaborate deception.
Two babies.
Two boys.
One family.
And a secret that had apparently been protected by lies, money, intimidation, and five years of silence.
Detective Laura Bennett finally broke the silence.
"Sarah, I need you to sit down."
Sarah didn't move.
"Tell me what this means."
The detective examined the photograph again.
"We're not going to draw conclusions until we have verified the medical records."
"There's another baby."
"Yes."
"And somebody took him."
"We don't know that yet."
Sarah looked toward Noah.
Her son was sitting upright in bed, gripping the blanket.
"Baby, what did you mean when you said Grandpa took the other one?"
Noah swallowed.
"When I was little, Rebecca showed me a picture."
"What picture?"
"Two babies in the hospital."
Sarah's heart tightened.
"Did she tell you who they were?"
"She said one was me."
"And the other?"
Noah looked down.
"She said he was my brother."
Sarah stared.
"Your brother?"
Noah nodded.
"She said he was born the same day. But Grandpa didn't want him."
Detective Bennett approached the bed.
"Noah, do you remember what Rebecca said happened to the other baby?"
Noah thought carefully.
"She said he went away."
"Where?"
"I don't know."
"Did she ever mention his name?"
Noah shook his head.
Then he suddenly looked at Sarah.
"She called him the forgotten one."
Sarah felt a chill.
The detective turned toward her.
"Did you ever know about a second pregnancy?"
Sarah shook her head.
"I was told I had one child."
"Do you remember the delivery?"
Sarah closed her eyes.
Fragments surfaced.
A hospital room.
A bright ceiling.
A nurse telling her to breathe.
Michael holding her hand.
The sound of a baby crying.
Then another sound.
A brief commotion.
A doctor saying something she couldn't understand.
Sarah opened her eyes.
"There was something."
Detective Bennett leaned closer.
"What?"
"I remember hearing two cries."
The room became silent.
Sarah pressed her fingers against her temples.
"I thought it was another mother in the next room. But I remember asking Michael why there were two babies crying."
"What did he say?"
"He told me the delivery room was busy."
Sarah looked at the photograph.
Then she remembered another detail.
A nurse had brought her a baby wrapped in a blue blanket.
But when she woke several hours later, the blanket was different.
She had asked where it went.
Michael told her the hospital had changed it.
She had never questioned him again.
"Find the doctor," Sarah whispered.
Detective Bennett nodded.
"Dr. Samuel Whitmore."
"Yes."
"We're already working on it."
"No. I want the original delivery records. Every page. Every signature. Every person who entered that room."
The detective looked at the prosecutor.
"We'll request the complete archive."
Noah suddenly spoke.
"Mommy?"
Sarah turned.
"Yes, sweetheart?"
"Can I tell you something?"
"Of course."
He looked toward the window.
"Rebecca said the other boy was supposed to live with you."
Sarah's breath caught.
"What?"
"She said Grandpa changed the papers because he wanted the other baby to have a different family."
"Why?"
Noah shook his head.
"She didn't tell me."
Sarah took his hand.
"Did you ever meet him?"
Noah hesitated.
Then nodded.
"When?"
"At the lake house."
Sarah leaned forward.
"What did he look like?"
Noah frowned.
"He looked like me."
Sarah stopped breathing.
"How old was he?"
"Maybe eleven."
"Eleven?"
Noah nodded.
"He had the same eyes. The same hair. But he had a scar."
"Where?"
Noah touched the area above his left eyebrow.
"Here."
Sarah remembered the photograph of Noah and Ethan from five years earlier.
The boy standing beside Ethan had a small scar above his left eyebrow.
But Noah had been wearing that blue sweater.
Sarah looked at her son.
"Are you sure?"
Noah nodded.
"He said his name was Noah."
Sarah felt the floor disappear beneath her.
Detective Bennett slowly straightened.
"Sarah, we need to verify something."
"What?"
"The photograph of the boys."
She turned toward the detective.
"Which photograph?"
"The one found on Ethan's phone. The one you showed us yesterday."
Sarah remembered.
Two boys standing outside their old house.
One was Ethan.
The other was supposed to be Noah.
But now there might have been another child.
Another boy who looked exactly like him.
Another boy who had been given the same name.
Detective Bennett took out her tablet.
She opened the photograph.
"Can you identify this child?"
Noah stared.
His face became pale.
Then he whispered:
"That's him."
Sarah's voice trembled.
"Who?"
May you like
Noah pointed at the screen.
"The other Noah."