talehub

Chapter 9 - THE BOY ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE DOOR

"Don't let her see the boy!"

Michael's voice echoed through the front hallway.

Sarah stood frozen beside the kitchen table, Noah's old phone trembling in her hand.

For five years, she had imagined hearing her missing son's voice again.

She had imagined running toward him, dropping everything, and holding him until neither of them could breathe.

She had never imagined that his first words would be a warning not to trust his own brother.

And she had certainly never imagined hearing her husband screaming at the police to keep her away from him.

"Sarah!" Detective Bennett shouted from the front entrance. "Open the door!"

Sarah looked at Ethan.

Her fifteen-year-old son stood near the kitchen island, his eyes fixed on the phone.

"Was that really Noah?" he whispered.

Sarah nodded.

Ethan's lips parted.

Then he began shaking his head.

"No."

"Ethan—"

"No, Mom. That's not possible."

"He's alive."

"No!"

The boy backed away.

Sarah reached toward him, but he recoiled.

"Why did he say not to trust me?"

Sarah had no answer.

Another knock shook the front door.

"Sarah, we need you to open this door immediately!"

She hurried into the hallway.

Before she could reach the lock, the door swung inward.

Detective Bennett entered with two uniformed officers.

Michael stood behind them.

His face was pale, his hair disheveled, and his shirt collar was open.

"Sarah, thank God."

He reached for her.

She stepped backward.

"Where is Noah?"

Michael stopped.

For several seconds, he looked at her without speaking.

Then he glanced toward Ethan.

"Where's the phone?"

Sarah tightened her grip.

"Answer my question."

"Sarah, you don't understand what's happening."

"Then explain it!"

Michael lowered his voice.

"Not in front of the children."

Detective Bennett stepped between them.

"Mr. Mitchell, you're going to explain everything at the station."

Michael looked at her.

"Detective, this is a family matter."

"No. A missing child is a police matter. Falsified reports, concealed evidence, and potential unlawful confinement are criminal matters."

Michael's jaw tightened.

Sarah watched him carefully.

She had once loved the man standing before her.

She had trusted him with her children, her home, her future.

Now she wondered how many nights he had slept beside her knowing that Noah was somewhere in the world, asking for his mother.

"Where is he?" she repeated.

Michael rubbed his forehead.

"I can bring him home."

Sarah's heart jumped.

"Where?"

"He's safe."

"Where is my son?"

Michael looked toward the staircase.

Then he said something that made Sarah's stomach tighten.

"He's at the house."

"What house?"

"The lake house."

Sarah recognized the location.

The Mitchell family owned a small property near Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. It had been purchased years before Noah disappeared and was rarely used.

Michael had told her that the property had been sold.

"That's impossible," Sarah whispered. "You sold it."

"I transferred the ownership."

"To whom?"

"Rebecca."

Detective Bennett immediately turned toward the officers.

"Get the address. Have local units check the property."

Michael shook his head.

"You're making a mistake."

"Then tell us where the boy is."

"He won't come willingly."

Sarah stared at her husband.

"Why?"

Michael's eyes moved toward Ethan.

"Because he's afraid."

"Of you?"

Michael didn't answer.

The silence was enough.

Detective Bennett instructed an officer to separate Michael from Sarah.

Michael resisted.

"Sarah, listen to me. Whatever Noah told you, it isn't the whole story."

She looked at him.

"He said he heard me calling his name."

Michael's face changed.

Sarah continued.

"He said he was trying to get out."

"Sarah—"

"He said you kept him somewhere."

Michael closed his eyes.

"I was protecting him."

"From what?"

"From the truth."

Sarah felt something cold settle inside her.

"What truth?"

Michael looked at Ethan.

Then he spoke quietly.

"That Noah was never supposed to be in this family."

Ethan made a strangled sound.

Sarah turned.

Her son was crying.

Michael continued.

"Five years ago, Noah discovered something in my office. Something about his birth. He started asking questions. He threatened to tell you."

Sarah shook her head.

"What are you talking about?"

Michael looked directly at her.

"Noah isn't biologically yours."

The words seemed to stop time.

Sarah stared.

"What?"

"He was adopted."

Sarah stepped backward.

"No."

"Sarah—"

"No! I gave birth to Noah!"

Michael looked down.

Then Detective Bennett spoke.

"Mr. Mitchell, I suggest you stop talking until you have legal counsel."

But Michael wasn't finished.

He looked at Sarah with an expression that was almost pleading.

"You need to understand. Everything I did was to keep this family together."

Sarah's eyes filled.

"You destroyed this family."

Then she turned to Detective Bennett.

"Take him away."

Michael was escorted outside.

As the front door closed, Sarah heard him shouting one final sentence.

"ASK REBECCA WHAT SHE DID TO THE FIRST BIRTH CERTIFICATE!"

Sarah stood motionless.

Then Ethan approached her.

"Mom?"

She turned.

He looked frightened.

"There's something else."

"What?"

Ethan swallowed.

"Before Noah disappeared, he told me something."

Sarah waited.

"He said he knew who his real mother was."

Sarah's breath caught.

"Who?"

Ethan looked toward the front door.

May you like

Then whispered:

"Rebecca."

Related Stories

Other posts