Chapter 3 - THE DRAWER THAT WAS SUPPOSED TO STAY LOCKED

The next morning, Sarah called in sick.
She told her supervisor that her daughter wasn't feeling well.
That wasn't entirely a lie.
Lily had barely spoken since the party.
She stayed close to Sarah, flinching whenever someone raised their voice.
Ethan, meanwhile, acted as though nothing had happened.
He came downstairs at 9:15 wearing a black sweatshirt.
He poured himself cereal.
He ignored his sister.
Then he asked for his birthday present.
Sarah stared at him.
"Good morning to you, too."
"Where's my computer?"
"We'll talk about that later."
"Mom."
"Ethan, we need to discuss what happened yesterday."
"I already said I was sorry."
"No, you didn't."
He dropped his spoon.
"Can we not do this again?"
"You hit Lily."
"She broke my cake!"
"And you raised your hand against me."
"You pushed me!"
"I was trying to protect myself."
Ethan laughed without humor.
"Of course. You're always the victim."
Sarah felt her jaw tighten.
"Go upstairs."
"Fine."
He grabbed his phone and left.
Sarah waited until she heard his bedroom door close.
Then she called her sister-in-law.
Rebecca answered on the third ring.
"Sarah! How's the birthday boy?"
"We need to talk."
A pause.
"About what?"
"Yesterday. And something else."
"Okay."
"Did you visit our old house the day Noah disappeared?"
Silence.
Long enough for Sarah to hear the faint television in the background.
"What?"
"September fourteenth. Five years ago. Were you at our house?"
Rebecca gave a nervous laugh.
"Sarah, that was a long time ago."
"That's not an answer."
"Why are you asking?"
"Because I found a photograph."
Another pause.
Then Rebecca spoke more quietly.
"You should leave the past alone."
Sarah felt her stomach drop.
"What did you say?"
"I said Noah is gone. You can't keep dragging everyone back into what happened."
"Why are you afraid of a photograph?"
"I'm not afraid."
"Then answer me."
Rebecca sighed.
"I have to go."
The call ended.
Sarah stared at her phone.
For the first time in five years, she wondered whether the tragedy that had destroyed her family had been investigated properly.
At 11:40, she went upstairs.
Ethan was in the shower.
His bedroom door was open.
Sarah intended to collect his laundry.
Instead, she noticed something unusual.
His desk drawer was locked.
Ethan had never locked his drawers before.
She tried the handle.
It wouldn't move.
She looked around.
A small brass key was lying beside his computer monitor.
Sarah hesitated.
Then she picked it up.
The lock clicked.
Inside were notebooks, old photographs, a broken watch, several birthday cards, and a small wooden box.
Sarah opened the box.
Her breath caught.
Three wrapped birthday presents lay inside.
All were addressed to the same name.
Noah Mitchell.
Sarah stared at them.
The first was a small silver airplane.
The second was a blue leather-bound journal.
The third was a miniature telescope.
Each had a different birthday card attached.
The handwriting was unmistakable.
It was Sarah's.
She recognized every letter.
Her own handwriting.
But she had never purchased these presents.
She had never wrapped them.
She had never written those cards.
She picked up the first envelope.
Happy ninth birthday, Noah. I hope you're watching the stars tonight. Mommy loves you forever.
Sarah's knees weakened.
The next card read:
Happy tenth birthday, my brave boy. I wish I could hold you just once more.
The final card was dated two months earlier.
Happy thirteenth birthday, sweetheart. I still think about you every morning.
Sarah's hands began shaking.
Why would Ethan have these?
Who had written them?
And why were they addressed to a boy who had died five years ago?
She examined the wrapping paper.
It was new.
The gifts had been purchased recently.
A small receipt was tucked beneath the telescope.
The purchase date was three weeks earlier.
The store was in downtown Chicago.
Sarah turned the receipt over.
A handwritten note appeared on the back.
For the birthday he never got to celebrate.
She sat down on Ethan's bed.
Her eyes filled with tears.
Then she noticed another envelope beneath the presents.
It was sealed.
Her name was written across the front.
Mom.
Sarah opened it.
Inside was a single photograph.
It showed Noah standing beside the old family house.
He was wearing the blue sweater from the picture on Ethan's phone.
But this photograph was different.
Noah wasn't smiling.
He was looking directly at the camera.
Behind him stood a second figure.
A man wearing a dark jacket.
Sarah turned the photograph over.
Five words were written on the back.
He was alive after the accident.
Her hands went numb.
A floorboard creaked behind her.
Sarah turned.
Ethan stood in the doorway.
His hair was wet.
His expression was unreadable.
For several seconds, mother and son stared at each other.
Then Ethan looked at the open drawer.
"You weren't supposed to find those."
Sarah held up the photograph.
"Ethan, what does this mean?"
He didn't answer.
"Who gave you these presents?"
Nothing.
"Why are they addressed to Noah?"
Ethan's jaw tightened.
Then he spoke.
"Because you keep pretending he's dead."
Sarah felt the room tilt.
"He's not?"
Ethan looked at her.
His eyes filled with tears.
"I don't know."
May you like
Then he stepped forward, snatched the photograph from her hand, and whispered:
"But somebody knows where he is."